VideoHelp Forum




+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 8 of 8
  1. I was thinking of getting this capture card, but out of all the details I don’t understand what EDID modes are meant to do.

    I guess also a side question would be, if capture cards in the $70-$200 range, like the one linked above, capture 4K then what would somebody need something like this? What is the targeted use for the higher end one? Should I consider that depending my needs?
    Last edited by nobodyhome; 19th Nov 2026 at 21:31.
    Quote Quote  
  2. Originally Posted by nobodyhome View Post
    I was thinking of getting this capture card, but out of all the details I don’t understand what EDID modes are meant to do.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_Display_Identification_Data

    I guess also a side question would be, if capture cards in the $70-$200 range, like the one linked above, capture 4K then what would somebody need something like this? What is the targeted use for the higher end one? Should I consider that depending my needs?
    What are your sources which you want to "capture"? (S-)VHS Tapes, Laserdiscs, V8, Hi8, D8, PC games, TV broadcast ....?
    Quote Quote  
  3. I’m aware what an EDID is. What I’m confused on is what EDID modes such as internal, merged, and display are meant to resolve so I determine if I need the feature or not.

    I’d be mostly capturing game and tv/streaming broadcasts, but when I have time I also aim be converting family vhs to disc/digital.
    Quote Quote  
  4. Originally Posted by nobodyhome View Post
    I’d be mostly capturing game and tv/streaming broadcasts ....
    Not my field of experience. Maybe someone else will chime in.

    ...but when I have time I also aim be converting family vhs to disc/digital.
    For capturing home VHS you can find plenty of information in this forum. To summarize the recommended process for obtaining good results which would fit your budget :
    - Use a tape player in good working condition, preferably a S-VHS model with internal TBC (Time Base Corrector) function. Not easy to find these days though.
    - If your tape player does not have TBC use a recommended DVD recorder in passthrough as a useful workaround to stabilize the picture (preventing line wiggle, minimizing glitches).
    - Capture losslessly interlaced 4:2:2 as 720x576 for PAL or 720x480 / 486) for NTSC, using a suitable capture card and free capture software.
    - Apply post processing, using your PC for deinterlacing, noise reduction, color grading, maybe upscaling .... you name it, and finally compression according your desired distribution format.

    If this sounds too complicated and/or you are not prepared to take the (initially steep) learning curve, you may head for an all-in-one box solution like the capture devices in your link - and accept what you get out of it.
    Quote Quote  
  5. Originally Posted by nobodyhome View Post
    I was thinking of getting this capture card, but out of all the details I don’t understand what EDID modes are meant to do.

    I guess also a side question would be, if capture cards in the $70-$200 range, like the one linked above, capture 4K then what would somebody need something like this? What is the targeted use for the higher end one? Should I consider that depending my needs?

    EDID modes allows one to customize the recording devices EDID to work with the HDMI video source "handshake".

    With HDMI, there is a digital "handshake" that happens between video source and the TV/monitor. The source reads the EDID info from the TV/Monitor and if it is a valid EDID then and only then will the video source make a connection to the TV/Monitor.

    If no EDID or a invalid EDID is returned the video source is supposed to refuse the connection and hence no video will be sent to the TV/Monitor..

    In most cases, HDMI devices like HDMI switches, port multipliers and even the HDMI video recorders you have posted will simply "pass" the EDID info from the TV/Monitor to the video source and become "the man in the middle" hijacking the digital stream in order to record.. If for any reason the EDID that is passed from the recorder doesn't work, you can try the other settings.

    The whole idea of using EDID handshake is to prevent one from being able to intercept, process and record digital high quality bit for bit copies of the source video stream.

    Some video sources like standalone game boxes, computers may not care unless you are playing commercial BR HD video discs, EDID is supposed to be strictly enforced on standalone BR players, Sat and cable boxes with HDMI outputs, but some may fall through the cracks and don't care so your mileage may vary..
    Quote Quote  
  6. EDID tell HDMI source what is your (HDMI sink/display/capture card) supported audio and video format and preferred audio/video format.
    You need to set in your capture card EDID with resolution you wish to capture then based on this your HDMI source will try to set resolution you prefer or other supported by your capture card resolution.

    EDID has nothing with HDCP (encryption) - DVI also use EDID and EDID was introduced with SVGA cards (so it has always at least two block, first one is computer like and additional blocks serve to signal customer (TV) parameters) - i simplified this as much as possible.

    Some capture cards may offer EDID cloning - i.e. they present to HDMI source a real EDID copied from your display and trying to identify as real TV - something similar to well known from networking "MAC cloning".

    Why EDID works like this - when EDID was created normally your monitor/display was equipped with small (128 bytes) I2C EEPROM so HDMI could read over I2C EEPROM content and based on this content your graphic source was able to display only video modes supported by monitor.
    Quote Quote  
  7. Member VWestlife's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2026
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Search PM
    I'm pretty sure EDID would only relate to capturing from VGA or DVI.
    Quote Quote  
  8. Actually EDID on HDMI does MUCH more than telling the source device what resolutions are supported.

    Back in VGA/DVI days that WAS all EDID did as there was no secret handshake involved.

    Fast forward to HDMI and things are a lot more complicated with the EDID as it is thought to be a part of the "handshake" chain that happens and while many can't agree, there is some agreement that EDID does indeed serve more functions in the handshake process than just to announce the resolutions supported by the monitor.

    Couple of the "data" points that is known to be communicated via EDID over HDMI is the "manufacturers ID", model number and even serial number of said viewing device, that info is critical to the source determining if the viewing screen is black listed or white listed (not allowed or allowed respectively).

    For strictly resolution adjustments there is zero "need" for any of these three pieces of info to be part of the EDID unless it was placed there to prevent viewing via an unauthorized method that could potentially expose the HD data stream. But it does stand to reason that EDID would be part of the key of the source determining if it is OK to send digital HD resolutions to your screen as the EDID is not scrambled or needing decoding.

    By the way, computer video cards and drivers will ignore a lot of the EDID provided you are not trying to play back copy protected HD material on BR in HD resolutions over HDMI, computer video cards with HDMI outputs are supposed to follow and obey any copy protection bits set on the disc.
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads