Bluray encode playback issue - choppy

[palaceplace]

Backing up some movies, used all the same encoding parameters, but 2 of them turned out to playback weirdly. On my ps3 these play but look like they are running at half their framerate, it's choppy. It plays at a normal rate, audio is fine too, but its chopped up like half the frames are missing. No artifacting or disc skipping either. Just choppy. Tried different media, different discs, different brands, different authoring software no luck.

Unfortunately I live in a more isolated place I just can't go run to someone's bluray player and test it, I use mainly my ps3 which does a good job of playing back many blurays. Again the issue is it looks choppy and it plays at half the framerate, but it doesnt artifact or slowdown, audio plays fine. All my other encodes were the same filetype, same audio type. I attached a small 10 second bluray ready compliant clip on one of them I am talking about. I'm not sure what's wrong. It plays well on the computer through arcsoft but suffers on the ps3. Once you download the clip and burn onto a bluray you will see what I mean. I have no clue what's wrong! Again plays fine through disc on my computer, but the bitrate is well balanced! it also does this on one of my 25mbps bluray encodes! no clue!

[Baldrick]

What do you encode with?
What do you author with?

[palaceplace]

What do you encode with?
What do you author with?

using sorenson squeeze

using the mainconcept encoder, could not get the x264 encoder encodes to be accepted into adobe encore without having to be transcoded. all were same settings, i attachdean image. these settings were the ones that were able to go inside adobe encore (and sony dvd architect allowed these as well). What I don't get is I encoded 30 movies with this same setting, of which 2 of them turned out only this way. I even tried re-encoding them to a lower bitrate of 15mbps with a max of 20mbps, and it's the same thing. It can't be a bitrate issue. Not hte audio either because others have same type of audio and play fine. Anyone want to test my clip on their bluray players? I'm stumped because they should all be playing perfectly, they used the same process for everything.

[jagabo]

Probably "keyframe ever 1 frames". Try 24.

[palaceplace]

Probably "keyframe ever 1 frames". Try 24.

Yep that was it, thanks.