My understanding is that a DVD compliant PAL mpg movie is 720 x 576 causing non-square pixels (PAR of 16:15) in order to deliver a DAR of 4:3.
Does this mean that when i see this mpg on a 4:3 computer monitor (full screen) I am actually seeing a slightly distorted (or is it cropped) video? If not how does it fit on a monitor which i read supports 1:1 pixel ratio
Now if i am using an image background image for a 4:3 PAL movie menu and assuming i do not want the authoring software to make changes and render what is ideal?
option 1 Crop the image to 720 x 576
option 2 Resize the image to 720 x 576 causing marginal though non-noticeable disproportionateness
....or have i got something completely wrong here in my understanding of these concepts
Thanks for any simple explanations or links towards them
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 4 of 4
-
-
The video frames will get scaled keeping the intended aspect ratio. At full screen and at "100%".
Originally Posted by perfection
I suppose you could make a 720x576 image with PAL PAR, if your authoring app lets you stretch it to (exactly) frame width after import. But what's the point? A background image shouldn't have to be pixel-precise and should be low contrast, non-distracting from the menu options, imho. -
To avoid rescaling, the menu background images should be:
4:3 = 768*576 pixels
16:9 = 1024*576 pixels -
You don't have to worry about TV DAR so much at this stage. Assuming you're using a square pixel PC monitor while editing (haven't come across otherwise), use minimums of 768x576 if you're doing a 4:3 menu and 1024x576 if 16:9. This is intended for you to view as you're creating it how it's going to look like on a TV that CORRECTLY displays it later. The authoring program will internally resize all these resolutions to 720x576, with flag unset for 4:3 and set for 16:9. 720x576 or 720x480 are DVD standards and you generally DON'T crop or resize images to them. Always stick to true blue square pixel 4:3 like 800x600, 768x576, etc. or 16:9 like 852x480, 1280x720, etc.
For the nth time, with the possible exception of certain Intel processors, I don't have/ever owned anything whose name starts with "i".
Similar Threads
-
Fastest way to burn using DVDA 5 - disk image or DAR file?
By jakgeoffsub in forum Authoring (DVD)Replies: 2Last Post: 11th Feb 2009, 23:29 -
Question how to change background menu picture on DVD
By jimdagys in forum Authoring (DVD)Replies: 15Last Post: 7th Dec 2008, 23:55 -
DVD Menu Image Buttons With Video Background
By sk8_aholic in forum Authoring (DVD)Replies: 3Last Post: 19th Nov 2008, 23:01 -
Mod16 question and DAR question...
By alcOre in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 5Last Post: 31st Oct 2008, 15:18 -
Quick question - PAL Menu when converting NTSC Xvid
By Azza_b in forum SVCD2DVD & VOB2MPGReplies: 2Last Post: 16th Oct 2007, 11:46