VideoHelp Forum




+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 26 of 26
  1. Whether it's one or more free programs I need maximum normalizing for both high volume and low volume. I have Goldwave and Audacity. I don't know which is more effective or there is a third choice.
    Quote Quote  
  2. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    Originally Posted by loninappleton View Post
    Whether it's one or more free programs I need maximum normalizing for both high volume and low volume. I have Goldwave and Audacity. I don't know which is more effective or there is a third choice.
    Normalize takes the highest peak of the existing audio up to 0db (maximum level) and the rest of the file is adjusted by the same amount -
    so the relative loudness between the parts of the file are the same - This may or may not be what you want,
    depends on the particulars of the file.

    Any of these Basic editors can do that, Audacity should be fine. I've never looked at Goldwave, so can't comment on that
    Quote Quote  
  3. Hello again Dave
    For many years I've used Levelator v2 from The Conversation network and I see it is in the videohelp software list. Highly recommended.
    So I always use that first. Normalizing, you said soothes off peaks. But this same audio has some very low volume parts and Levelator did not do enough (if anything) with those. I've experimented with raising the volume on those sections in Audacity but no consistent result. Those quiet parts are the chief problem. And a lot of waveform is just 'off the top' of the graph from an on the fly mix is my guess. Levelator didn't work it's magic on those quiet low volume parts which I think came from editing together two sources. I think I've had part of this discussion with jagabo already asking about how to use Audacity. Part of this is just my difficulty using audio software.
    Quote Quote  
  4. sound to me more like drc instead of normalization is what you want.
    users currently on my ignore list: deadrats, Stears555, marcorocchini
    Quote Quote  
  5. Hello again Selur.

    I appreciate the advice. What is a good program for that? Your link shows it is in Audacity 4. I can et the new version though it's likely in v3 as well. I have on PC that can run v4 and and older one that, with old AMD can run 3.
    Quote Quote  
  6. Audacity 4 (version 4.0.0) was released on September 3, 2026. Alternatively if no gui is needed, one could use sox (or sox_ng) and it's compand option.
    That said Audacity 3 also should have the compressor.
    Since you mentioned Goldwave, it should also offer drc (https://goldwave.com/help/mobile/EffectExpander.html).
    users currently on my ignore list: deadrats, Stears555, marcorocchini
    Quote Quote  
  7. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    Lon it might be helpful if you could upload a minute or two of the uncompressed audio,
    something that shows the quiet and loud parts that you're trying to better balance
    Quote Quote  
  8. @ davexnet
    Yes it's always difficult to explain things by long distance. My editing is pretty rusty but over the days will see what I can do.
    Quote Quote  
  9. You can use any audio software equipped in dynamics compressor - players like foobar2000 are capable to use compressor and render audio file to desired format for example https://www.foobar2000.org/components/view/foo_dsp_vlevel .

    Personally to normalize loudness i use ffmpeg with filter
    Code:
    dynaudnorm=p=1/sqrt(2):m=100:s=20
    - it normalize level and apply small dynamic compression at the same time.

    You can also use Audition (version 3 as Adobe released registration key - there is few different compressors with various settings).
    Last edited by pandy; 20th Nov 2026 at 13:54.
    Quote Quote  
  10. My understanding of audio software is the bare minimum. But after running Levelator (which other users say there are better tools)
    I'm using Goldwave and its preset first for ' boost the quiet parts ' (their phrase) and in a second pass 'reduce the loud parts.' These are all saved in separate MP3s.

    Then in Audacity I'll reload the program and just visually see if things have levelled out. Goldwave was a program I first bought when
    trying to do audio-- pops and click etc close to 25 years ago. My subscription never ran out thanks to the developer. So I'll see what happens. Gw has had regular updates. There may be a similar sequence for Audacity. I like the idea of presets so far.
    Quote Quote  
  11. Today I am trying to make that clip using the original audio from the mp4. without a lot of explain I'm using Goldwave because it _sounds_ like it will cut it correctly and drop off everything else. I thought I had it in Audacity trim front, trim remainder save the highlighted area. Didn't work, the audio went elsewhere and I have no idea why.
    Quote Quote  
  12. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    To select audio in Audacity, click the mouse in the waveform where you want to the clip to start. Hold down the shift key and click the spot where you want the selection to end.
    File / Export Audio - set the format to Wav/Microsoft
    Export Range - current selection - save it on your Desktop

    Upload the WAV file
    Quote Quote  
  13. I have a good clip attached. At least it played and shows the big drop in volume. About 3 mins. It's dialog from a play that begins at volume then there's a sound effect of static for the scene change then the same two are having some "pillow talk" and that three mins more or less is where the problem is.

    Elsewhere though I'm not getting all the meters in the red for the excessive audio.
    I've used mkvtoolnix to remux the full audio with the boost and reduction mentioned above and will play that back.

    --
    Dave, we crossed comments. I'll review that in a bit.
    I'm glad I got something to work anyway.
    Image Attached Files
    Quote Quote  
  14. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    Here's a couple of attempts, clip-a uses the legacy compressor, Amplify, Noise reduction (for that funky sound @ 12 seconds in)
    then Amplify again on the quite talk in the middle using a selection.

    Clip-b uses the legacy compressor, Amplify and Noise reduction as before, then Export out as a 32-bit WAV into Levelator, then the output from that back into Audacity and Amplify again to reduce the level of the whole file.

    The Levelator version seems to introduce a slight reverb to the sound (that's a matter of preference)
    Image Attached Files
    Quote Quote  
  15. I appreciate the time you've taken with this. I'll load the two clips to see how the waveform looks.
    Since there are two spots that have the level change (all due to the live shoot they did with lots of moving parts)
    this should run throuh the whole 2 hours of the video.

    Aside from the clip, for the whole file what is the sequence?

    1. Amplify (the original)
    2. Levelator
    3. Amplify the Levelator WAV output file which Levelator creates.

    We weren't using amplify but boost and reduction which is where I am with applying effects.
    Quote Quote  
  16. This is a screen shot of the boost routine in Goldwave showing the preset.
    Following your lead of doing the task twice for more 'amplify' I ran the boost quiet parts twice to see what that does. I did not twiddle with the preset at all since I don't understand the terms well enough and would get more bad results.

    I'll play your clips tomorrow. T
    Image Attached Thumbnails Click image for larger version

Name:	boost quiet in Goldwave.png
Views:	7
Size:	272.2 KB
ID:	94392  

    Quote Quote  
  17. Last thing today. I went back to Audacity and I see where 'Amplify' is at effects > volume and compression. But still not clear on the exact process for this task in Audacity.
    Quote Quote  
  18. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    Originally Posted by loninappleton View Post
    Last thing today. I went back to Audacity and I see where 'Amplify' is at effects > volume and compression. But still not clear on the exact process for this task in Audacity.
    Amplify is synonymous with Gain. It's a control to increase or reduce (negative gain) the level by a certain amount of dB.
    Here I show the base view(unchanged) aud1.png, after the legacy compressor (to tame the peaks) aud2.png,
    then Amplify on the whole file to increase its level by approx 7dB, aud3.png,
    then select the quiet audio in the middle and Amplify again approx 6.5dB, aud4.png,
    Settings of the legacy compressor, aud5.png
    Image Attached Thumbnails Click image for larger version

Name:	aud1.png
Views:	6
Size:	43.7 KB
ID:	94393  

    Click image for larger version

Name:	aud2.png
Views:	3
Size:	40.7 KB
ID:	94394  

    Click image for larger version

Name:	aud3.png
Views:	3
Size:	48.3 KB
ID:	94395  

    Click image for larger version

Name:	aud4.png
Views:	3
Size:	60.1 KB
ID:	94396  

    Click image for larger version

Name:	aud5.png
Views:	4
Size:	11.0 KB
ID:	94397  

    Quote Quote  
  19. Done with clever FFmpeg-GUI ,DynAudNorm Filter gain +12dB.
    Image Attached Files
    Quote Quote  
  20. @ ProWo
    Ok more options and more than I can handle . The loads of these audio files takes forever. I took a chance on ordering additional (used) memory for my older machine that uses DDR3. It should be here relatively soon. I've run Clever ffmpeg just to see how it worked but nwver did any jobs in it.
    Does the command run on the whole file w/o multiple steps: just set and forget for the whole two hours run time?
    Quote Quote  
  21. Originally Posted by loninappleton View Post
    @ ProWo
    Ok more options and more than I can handle . The loads of these audio files takes forever. I took a chance on ordering additional (used) memory for my older machine that uses DDR3. It should be here relatively soon. I've run Clever ffmpeg just to see how it worked but nwver did any jobs in it.
    Does the command run on the whole file w/o multiple steps: just set and forget for the whole two hours run time?
    Yes, the whole file.
    Quote Quote  
  22. Sounds like a great solution if it reduces all the loads and steps.

    For Clever FFmpeg GUI can you give a few steps to do the task? Unfortunately anything much beyond drag and drop and I'd be lost.

    I see that I'll have to reinstall it first on second PC here. No rush. Also I'm slow to answer replies sometimes. I'll see what I can find on videohelp
    software.
    Quote Quote  
  23. I finally listened to the clips and dave and ProWo both sound a lot better that what I was getting.
    And I see the value of working with clips rather than what I was doing waiting for the whole file to load over and over. I have to try the method from Dave first to get the steps straight.

    The FFMpeg is the better only because I hear even more 'gain or volume on that clip though because I noticed as I worked on my subtitling task for the play that there's another and possibly _other_ of those quiet spots.

    I appreciate your patience and help.
    Last edited by loninappleton; 21st Nov 2026 at 15:38.
    Quote Quote  
  24. I'll continue setup of FFMpeg and Clever GUI here.

    So far I read the readme from the zip on clever ffmpeg.

    I made a folder in programs called FFMPeg 9.01
    I put the zip file of clever mpeg gui
    and the recommended build of FFMPEG proper in it.

    Next I would unzip FFMpeg main program
    then follow that with
    unzip clever mpeg.

    or not?

    I simply need all the steps to do this (with no gotchas.)
    Quote Quote  
  25. Originally Posted by loninappleton View Post
    I'll continue setup of FFMpeg and Clever GUI here.

    So far I read the readme from the zip on clever ffmpeg.

    I made a folder in programs called FFMPeg 9.01
    I put the zip file of clever mpeg gui
    and the recommended build of FFMPEG proper in it.

    Next I would unzip FFMpeg main program
    then follow that with
    unzip clever mpeg.

    or not?

    I simply need all the steps to do this (with no gotchas.)
    1) Create a folder with name FFmpeg.
    2) Unzip the whole content of the downloaded FFmpeg binaries in folder 1)

    3) Create another folder with name clever FFmpeg GUI ( NOT in 1) and unzip the whole content of clever_ffmpeg_gui_360.zip into 3).
    4) Start clever FFmpeg-GUI.exe in 3) and follow the instructions (2 steps to locate the bin folder of ffmpeg and a target folder to hold the output files).
    5) If this is done, click settings, update and update to the latest nightly offered.

    6) Now you're ready to go.
    Drag your video/audiofile into the main page, wait for the analysis, click Encode audio stream, set the encoder and the bitrate, click Set filter, check the DynAudNorm checkbox.

    Image
    [Attachment 94406 - Click to enlarge]


    A new window with the DynAudNorm settings pops up. Enter here the gain you want to apply (with your file 12dB, but in most cases a value from 2-6dB is enough). Leave all other settings as they are. Click OK.

    Image
    [Attachment 94407 - Click to enlarge]


    Finally click encode.
    Quote Quote  
  26. Thanks to clea I beleive I have duplicated Dave's steps. In the images, the Legacy Compressor is shown last so I don't know if it's run again.


    But I hand wrote notes for the followsing

    Base view from original mp4
    run Audacity > Effects > Volume > Legacy Compressor
    run Effects > volume > Amplify to 7.db in that dialog and Apply
    Select the quiet part and Go Effect > Volume > Amplify to 6.5
    The ignore clipping box is checked

    SAVE

    But my question was is Legacy Compressor shown last run again?

    And is it possible to get just a little more gain/ volume to match level on what follows and precedes that edited part?

    This is a major accomplishment for me even on a clip. How the new Audacity 4 changes any of this I wonder.
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads