I've just made my first DVD from old VHSs (in fact I've made two!). I was absolutely delighted with the results until, after playing certain chapters several times, the audio would start to break up and skip, this fault being accompanied by large areas of ugly blockiness appearing on the video in seemingly random places. Eventually it will all turn really ugly and freeze. Now of course, I'm wondering whether it's the software or the media I've used.
What I've done is recorded the VHSs onto Maxell DVD-RWs using a JVC DR-M10 (XP mode), used TMPGEnc DVD Author to get the DVD video files onto my HDD, done all the authoring, then burned it onto a Maxell DVD-R using TDA's writing function. This media has ID RITEKG04, and I didn't find it particularly clear on DigitalFAQ.com whether this was meant to be any good or not.
What I've done is burned three tracks (which were recorded on XP mode) of approximately 20 minutes each (this comes to 4376 out of 4438MB according to TDA), and so far it has only been the third track which is playing up. I've heard this is because of the outer limits of the DVD spinning faster and therefore being more susceptible to fault, particularly if you're near to maximum capacity. However, my second DVD is only 2704/4438MB and the third track is still faulty, although only a few minutes before the end (not right at the end).
Sorry for ranting on but you need to know the facts if anybody's to help! Does this sound like a media problem? The whole point of converting to DVD is so I can keep my videos on a safe format for a long time, so how can I make a good, stable disc?
P.S. Oh yeah I'm pretty sure this is not a player problem - the JVC had problems playing it and so did my Toshiba SD220E, although the DVD player on my PC played it fine, oddly enough.
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 30 of 33
-
-
1) Place disc data-side down on end table
2) Place drink glass on it
Get new media -
Originally Posted by Capmaster
Or you could make a frisbee out of it.
-
Well that sounds pretty conclusive! Trouble is I've just gone and bought a fat load of the discs
I thought Maxell were pretty good but I guess I made mistake numero uno - went for the brand.
Does anybody in the UK know of a retailer that sells the kinds of discs that are recommended here (MXLRG01, TDKG02, etc)? There are so many people here talking about where they get their media in the US, but I'm lost when it comes to buying across the pond from you guys. -
Hint: Buy Taiyo Yuden. It's harder to find in the UK and more expensive, but if you're getting piles of coasters from the Maxells, they look much more reasonable
Maxell used to use TYG01 for their 4X, along with Ritek G03. The TY were excellent, the Ritek were just OK. Sounds like they went to Ritek G04 for their 8x. I've been hearing many bad things about Ritek G04 lately.
You can buy TY media in the UK here:
http://www.cd-rduplicators.co.uk/media.htm -
The brand can be misleading, what matters is the media code. You can buy what appear to be the same disks and find out they come from different sources.
I use www.svp.co.uk because they show you the media codes. I'm very happy with the Verbatim -R's I bought from them (MCC). They are about £27 for 50. Never heard a bad word said about them. -
Capmasters right Taiyo Yuden are the best but expensive. You get what you pay for! You can buy them at www.svp.co.uk also and there cheaper. God I sound like a sales rep. Maybe they'll give me commision for all this advertising
-
Thanks a lot guys, that's been a great help
I'm relieved that it's probably down to bad media rather than some other terminal problem. I'll give it a crack with some new media, and only if it doesn't work will I post back here... so hopefully we'll never see this thread again! -
Originally Posted by tim6661234
No problem with the help. I hope you get it sorted with some good media -
Originally Posted by Capmaster
Try some datawrite 8x printables using the Fuji03 dye..From either svp or ukdvdr both good online UK stores. Ukdvdr has the edge at the moment know a few people who have had issues with packing from svp, replaced without a problem but its a pain when what you order arrives in bits...
Ty's are over priced in the Uk even svp want £69 for 100..... datawrite fuji 03 £23 for 100 no contest really and the quality is just a good.... Having said that i'm still getiing good results with riteks both 04 & 05 dye....Not bothered by small problems...
Spend a night alone with a mosquito -
RITEKG0x ... 2nd class ... at best these days, not worst like it used to be.
www.nomorecoasters.com
Better stuff exists, some of it cheaper.Want my help? Ask here! (not via PM!)
FAQs: Best Blank Discs • Best TBCs • Best VCRs for capture • Restore VHS -
Originally Posted by iooi
http://www.ukdvdr.co.uk/shop/customer/home.php
Anyone tried the new Datawrite Yellow 8X (CMC) speed yet? Any good? -
MCC
http://www.ukdvdr.co.uk/shop/customer/product.php?productid=17299&cat=0&page=1
I'd think these were good. Probably MCC 02RG20
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
CMC MAG AE1
http://www.ukdvdr.co.uk/shop/customer/product.php?productid=17307&cat=0&page=1
... supposedly MCC dye made on CMC equipment. .. cannot confirm
if true, may be good.Want my help? Ask here! (not via PM!)
FAQs: Best Blank Discs • Best TBCs • Best VCRs for capture • Restore VHS -
I'm curious, you didn't by any chance put a label on these DVD's, did you? The symptoms sound similar to what happened to me when I did that.
-
Nope, no labels - I read that labels can cause trouble so I avoided them.
Cheers for the tip, lordsmurf. -
Originally Posted by monzie
yeh i tried them 2 spindles,just as bad as i remember.
supposidly a ritek G04/M02 dye,my arse.
just as well they sent them to me in my order by mistake,i might have paid for them too,if they were any good.
ring burns,and black spots after burning,movie skips,pauses,eventually stops-welcome back to the days of princo.
IMO,there just reprinted crap,
the grey ones with the Fuji03 or prodiscF01 dye are brilliant though,so ill stick with them for the foreseeable future. -
cheap=a good way to decorate your xmas tree this year
PhenII 955@3.74 - GA-790XTA-UD4 AM3 - 2x4 Corsair Vengeance@1600 - Radeon 5770 - Corsair 550VX - OCZ Agility 3 90GB WD BLACK 1TB - LiteOn 24x - Win 8 Preview - Logi G110+G500 -
Originally Posted by glockjsNot bothered by small problems...
Spend a night alone with a mosquito -
Before you use all of the ritek as coasters, try burning the files at 2x speed. I bought 25 of these, burnt 5 at 8x and got 5 coasters. I burned the rest at 2x and everyone burnt flawlessly.
I have also switched to TY discs and so far have not made a coaster. -
Originally Posted by iooiPhenII 955@3.74 - GA-790XTA-UD4 AM3 - 2x4 Corsair Vengeance@1600 - Radeon 5770 - Corsair 550VX - OCZ Agility 3 90GB WD BLACK 1TB - LiteOn 24x - Win 8 Preview - Logi G110+G500
-
Originally Posted by RottenFoxBreath
-
Originally Posted by dartboard
Thanks for the 2x tip. I'll give it a try. -
The TY discs are a little too pricey for me! They only seem to sell them in packs of 100 or more... I generally only need 10 at a time, at most! That would last me a few months.
On the same SVP site they have Verbatim 8x pastel discs, these are Taiyo Yuden discs also, they are cheaper than the other Taiyo Yuden discs they sell and you can buy them in packs of 5 if you only used small quantities. Unfortunately they are out of stock at the moment but i would expect them to get more in very soon.
Hammy -
Originally Posted by hammy
-
Those "Taiyo Yuden" DVDs people go on about might be the bees knees (never used them) but £119 for 100 is just ridiculous.
I personally use the Datawrite illuminous yellow 8x (burn at 12x) +R (Prodisc R03) and never had a problem, they are only £30 for 100. -
Originally Posted by Paul_GTaiyo Yuden (8x) Printable DVD-R in Heavy Duty Spindle Tubs of 100
£59.98 -
Originally Posted by Paul_G
Just an FYI. This is just one of several UK web based suppliers that are always listed whenever anybody posts asking for reliable and cheap UK DVDr supplies. A simple search in the media forum should turn up the others.
Similar Threads
-
Set "Output filename" As Default Global "File/segment title" In MkvMerge?
By LouieChuckyMerry in forum Video ConversionReplies: 0Last Post: 9th Jul 2011, 01:52 -
WMV files: Changing "Recorded Date", "Media Created" fields in metadata
By axhack in forum EditingReplies: 5Last Post: 18th Sep 2010, 01:27 -
"stretching" or "cramming" aspect ratio when I convert .avi to MP4
By Agent Bauer in forum ffmpegX general discussionReplies: 3Last Post: 21st Mar 2010, 10:30 -
Editorial: Why "HD DVD" Is Thumping "Blu-ray Disc"
By Specialist in forum Latest Video NewsReplies: 146Last Post: 16th Feb 2008, 08:08 -
Review "HYFAI" MP3/MP4 "Nano" clone from ebay
By NG in forum Portable VideoReplies: 29Last Post: 18th Sep 2007, 05:45