Two years ago, I started a project to digitize a friend's ~1000 hours of VHS hifi-audio tapes. These are EP mode tapes of field recordings, where 90% of the content is hifi audio only (no video).
I have little-to-no prior VHS experience, so this has been quite the learning journey (gory details here: https://www.reddit.com/r/filk/comments/1xun4zg/how_i_spent_1700_learning_the_hard_way_to/ )
It's clear from the 5 VHS's I've used that some of them are better than others at playing back VHS Hifi when there's no video signal. Are there specific US-based consumer models that are strongly recommended for Hifi audio-only playback? (I don't care about video quality; I have an S7600U and S9500U for video+audio content)
The main one I'm seeing seems to be the Mitsubishi HS-U748.
I'm just wondering if there are others that may be easier to find, or ones that are even better?
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 16 of 16
-
-
I have a Panasonic DMR-EZ48V vhs/dvd combo deck that has excellent hifi sound. It digitises the audio (and video) internally and outputs over HDMI, so it's possible to capture the digitised signal straight off the deck without additional ADC conversions.
-
I don't think having a HDMI port means the audio is going from RF to digital directly, There is a stage where HiFi RF is demodulated into analog audio and then digitized along the video into HDMI signal. He can give HiFi-decode (part of VHS-decode) a shot, It picks up RF HiFi audio and process it in digital without going through the mandatory RF to analog audio used by regular VCRs.
-
-
I'm open to trying that. It looks like a complete Domesday Duplicator is pushing $575 nowadays? https://www.ebay.com/itm/326651085769
-
You can tune a VCR for HiFi playback only easily if the VCR has the motor drum stator on top, Basically loosen the top stator mounting screws ever so slightly that you can twist the stator PCB left and right without being completely loose, go very slowly on each direction until you hear no buzzing sound and tighten the screws, Be carful not to touch the spinning drum.
Note: Doing this will mess up the head switch at the bottom of the image, So if you plan on using the VCR for video you can follow my procedure here explained in the video description, I meant to release an audio version when I get a proper microphone setup but things keep getting in the way. -
-
Here is what they suggested for capturing RF Hi-Fi audio only, It's a USB dongle capable of decoding Hi-Fi audio and saving it @ 24bit 48KHz.
-
You can also use a HSDAOH device to do dual channel RF capture as well as 4 simultaneous analog captures via HDMI with custom drivers. Works with the same MISRC app or can be used via the command line.
I am going to be putting out kits that are unassembled for $225 without the 3D printed case or $250 unassembled with the 3D printed case if anyone is interested. The kits will require some basic soldering as well as more advanced SMD component replacement, but all components will be included in the kits including screws, spacers, and other hardware.
The assembled one I made did sell for $370 or so here, but it'll give you an idea what the finished product looks like:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/940024119120
If you want an unassembled kit shipped directly to you within the USA, I can do 10% off those prices, just PM me on videohelp here with your paypal email address, how many kits you want, and with or without 3D printed case.
Agree if you're just doing hifi capture that it's overkill to be able to capture via HSDAOH though.
-
Those prices defeat the purpose of vhs-decode being cheaper than the conventional capture, not to mention the headache of setting up the whole thing and tweaking it as you go just to get a similar capture quality.
-
From a prosumer capture or decode?
That's just another method, I'd rather take that than waiting for ages on the new MISRC version that is probably already sold out on pre-orders in which I'd only use for less then 10 tapes total.
It's either that or buy a complete Domesday Duplicator setup for around $500. I think the MISRC will probably be priced for around $300 to $400 too... -
You can certainly source all the parts for a Dual HSDAOH device for maybe 25% less, but you run the risk of certain items being dead on arrival, individual items getting lost in the mail coming from China, and ending up being required to buy extra parts that you don't need for a single build.
Decode can still be inexpensive. If that's the goal, you'd go with a CX cards, though that still is suggested to have a clockgen mod and possibly some other mods which further complicates the setup and you need to use that with a desktop PC that can accept PCIe cards. The other options are nice because they can be used via USB3 and do not require desktop computers.
The MISRC v2.5 when more widely available is expected to cost around $750 pre-assembled from what I've seen.
I wouldn't call decode setups "cheaper" for most - what you save in monetary value, you generally pay for in learning curve, non-realtime capture results, potential for audio sync issues, need for large amounts of hard drive space to archive and handle intermediate stages, while possibly having similar results to traditional capture with nice equipment. You may not actually capture anything with a decode setup if you get frustrated by the learning curve and initial hardware setup.
Recent implementations have helped with the learning curve part by relying more user friendly GUIs, but this isn't something you'd ship to your grandmother and expect her to be able to capture video with at all using their home VCR. No matter which decode option you go with, it does require some soldering on the playback device which is a little bit of a learning curve in and of itself. It's not insurmountable, but the more barriers to enter, the less user friendly. Having a kit with all the parts needed to build one does remove some barriers to entry, but not all. You still need to have soldering skills and mod the VCR itself, usually you'd also want to put a Rene Wolfe amplifier in as well to get the RF levels up to what the capture device is expecting. This is true with all RF capture devices though including the Cx cards, MISRC, and HSDAOH.
I also don't know anyone that actually uses Decode for the cost savings, they tend to use it for a more accurate archival copy of what's actually on the tape that won't need to be recaptured later if the decode software improves later over time, or they may prefer the look of it to what they were getting with their specific traditional capture setup. I dabble with Decode, but for me, it's not worth the hard drive space to archive hundreds of hours of home movies that likely will only ever be watched a handful of times ever again. For select tapes of historical value, I see the value of an RF capture as well as it could eventually be viewed by thousands or millions of people if posted online and there's enough interest in the content. -
And to think they promote like it's so easy. No it ain't.
I bet there are a ton of people who are interested in the method, but do not go any further because of all the technical problems. There is an audience for people who just want a full workflow that just works right out of the box.
And what about people who can't solder due to physical handicaps.
Meh I don't want to derail this thread. People can use decode but it should not be promoted as the one and only method that everybody on the planet should use in the context of consumer analog tape, the more uncommon professional formats would have more of a use case imo.
Well respected transfer services run by actual established professionals don't use it such as George Blood LP, my local transfer service who has had an online website since the mid 90s doesn't use it, I think that is saying something. I bet most professional archivists don't use it, not any museums or institutions anyway. -
It was launched as cost saver, Also the promise of capture now and decode later has been already broken, Few years after the initial vhs-decode launch some members have recaptured their tapes more than once already due to hardware bugs and necessary changes.
-
Yeah like any decode capture from before 2025 is now basically unusable as it worse than what a proper prosumer capture could do even back then.
I've seen them, they have awful ringing issues. A problem that still has not been fully solve, and who knows if it ever will, they seemingly do not view it as an issue.
So the method still isn't better, it's a bit worse. I'd say that leaves the method to be different, no different than capturing using SDI.
Similar Threads
-
Video playback on Chrome vs. Firefox audio sync different, why?
By BosseB in forum Software PlayingReplies: 0Last Post: 20th Jan 2025, 04:21 -
Is my DMR-ES16 a one-off, or is this thing the Holy Grail?
By bmichaelb in forum Capturing and VCRReplies: 4Last Post: 21st Nov 2024, 12:02 -
SVHS TBC and HiFi Audio Dropouts
By IcePhoenix07 in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 4Last Post: 4th Nov 2024, 04:32 -
Panasonic NV-HS800 doesn't output video but does output HiFi audio
By golenman123 in forum RestorationReplies: 2Last Post: 15th Oct 2022, 15:49 -
PotPlayer - UHD Disc playback - getting audio but no video!
By thinredline in forum Software PlayingReplies: 11Last Post: 17th Aug 2022, 16:46



Quote