I understand that when capturing video, one should adjust the pro-amp settings in VirtualDub to brightness within the 16–235 range. And to do this, one turns on the histogram in VirtualDub, plays the scene of video, and adjusts the brightness and contrast until the levels are in the safe blue zone, and not in the unsafe red zones on the right and left.
Question: I have read that the ATI 9600XT can capture illegal values (those in the red zone), but that other devices like the ATi600 cannot. Does the ability to capture illegal values mean that slightly blown out whites and darks can be adjusted in post to restore some of the detail? Or does it mean something else?
Try StreamFab Downloader and download from Netflix, Amazon, Youtube! Or Try DVDFab and copy Blu-rays!
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 9 of 9
Thread
-
-
Basically one can correct and restore the levels in post as long as the signals reside within the 0 .... 255 range (verified by means of the histogram and/or the waveform monitor) and are not clipped. Note that clipping may happen at any stage in the signal flow, so one may actually see clipped signals which are within the stated range. Once a signal is clipped the details are lost and can't be recovered.
Last edited by Sharc; 25th Sep 2024 at 16:43.
-
Just for clarity, note that values less than 0 and more than 255 can't be represented in 8 bit caps. Any pixels that would have been outside the 0 to 255 range are crushed to those extremes. For example, a pixel that was supposed to be at -20 will be clipped at 0 instead; a pixel that was supposed to be 275 will be clipped at 255. As Sharc said, you want to avoid hard clipping as that will lose details in the dark and light areas, details that you might otherwise be able to recover.
-
Follow up question. I've noticed that when I use my MiniDV camcorder as the digitization device for Video8 footage, I am able to restore blown out whites in post. Does this suggest that MiniDV as a digitizer has the same illegal value pardoning power as the ATI AIW 9600XT
-
-
Not really. You should adjust the input range in order to be captured by your card. Generally something like 16-252/254. You can see an overview of the most common capture range here: https://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/video-capture/9865-canopus-advc-110-a.html#post62640
After, if you need a RGB conversion for processing or display, you reduce the levels to 16-235 in software, which is more accurate than with the procamp of the cards. -
Take note though that such YUV->RGB (and subsequent RGB->YUV) conversion may - depending on the tool - take place "silently" without one being aware of. Then the damage is there.
Capturing deliberately into the "red" luma zone with useful picture content (means other than halos and noise) is prone to causing trouble IMO, unless one knows exactly what one is doing.
Capturing too cautious on the other hand reduces SNR and may tend towards banding, but we are still talking (S-)VHS quality.....Last edited by Sharc; 26th Sep 2024 at 04:44.
-
Take note though that such YUV->RGB (and subsequent RGB->YUV) conversion may - depending on the tool - take place "silently" without one being aware of. Then the damage is there.
unless one knows exactly what one is doing
Capturing too cautious on the other hand reduces SNR and may tend towards banding, but we are still talking (S-)VHS quality
Similar Threads
-
ATI AIW 7500 AGP Radeon Capture Big Problem
By theseeker2 in forum CapturingReplies: 56Last Post: 23rd May 2023, 17:36 -
ATI AIW Radeon 7500 AGP Capture Levels and Histogram in VirtualDub
By theseeker2 in forum CapturingReplies: 8Last Post: 3rd May 2023, 20:06 -
Unable to launch ATI video capture with ATI TV Wonder USB2.0 (WinXP ProSP3)
By Darryl In Canada in forum CapturingReplies: 1Last Post: 30th Aug 2022, 15:34 -
ATI All-in-wonder 9600XT installation/configuration issues
By rgia in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 13Last Post: 21st May 2020, 19:02 -
Ati aiw 8500
By Smack2k in forum CapturingReplies: 0Last Post: 4th Dec 2019, 13:00