TMPGEnc is the worst program ever.

[SonyVega]

This program has caused so much frustration in my life in the past few weeks. Encoding DVDs is more trouble than it's worth. I cannot go through an encode session without getting some module error which stop my encoding dead in it's tracks. I am trying an old SVCD to DVDR following all instructions here, even convereted the audio to WAV but still no go. i've tried old versons, new versons, but they all give the same read/write module errors. My system specs is

Gigabyte GA-7VAX
AMD Athlon 1600 XP
512MB PC2700 RAM
WD 120GB 8MB cache HD

Thanks for any help.

[SaSi]

Don't discard a program before you've given it a chance. Guessing from your words, you are not new into this, but were doing SVCDs in the past and now move on to DVD. Continuing to guess, you have tried lot's of programs and converters and codecs and you have installed them all onto your PC.

If my guessing is right, then it's perhaps time to freshen up your operating system installation. All these tools, utilities and programs around are not exactly high-quality, tested programs and several cause problems to others.

Has happened to me, Tmpgenc has been doing a great job for some time, both MPEG1 and MPEG2. After trying several codecs for AVI capture and a few other MPEG encoders, I ended up with both Tmpgenc and DivX doing garbage and Tmpgenc crashing without an apparent reason.

Re-installed the operating system, drivers, service packs and ONLY essential s/w AND no codecs. Then I took a snapshot backup, just in case. Then I re-installed only the essential encoders and codecs. They are all working like a breeze now. The system is even a bit faster and more responsive. And I can test anything and have a chance to go back without spending hours in re-installation.

Tmpgenc can do good encoding but is slow. It's not a program that just crashes for no reason.

Also, if you have installed DirectX 9, don't re-install it after (if) you re-install your system. Stick to DX8.1 It has all the functionality you need and doesn't cause problems to several programs (as DX9 does).

[puertorican138]

This program has caused so much frustration in my life in the past few weeks. Encoding DVDs is more trouble than it's worth. I cannot go through an encode session without getting some module error which stop my encoding dead in it's tracks. I am trying an old SVCD to DVDR following all instructions here, even convereted the audio to WAV but still no go. i've tried old versons, new versons, but they all give the same read/write module errors. My system specs is

Gigabyte GA-7VAX
AMD Athlon 1600 XP
512MB PC2700 RAM
WD 120GB 8MB cache HD

Thanks for any help.

TMPGEnc is not the worst program ever! You probably just don't know how to use it. Once you learn how to configure and tweak TMPGEnc, you will love it!!!

[eats**t&die]

Tmpgenc can do good encoding but is slow. It's not a program that just crashes for no reason.

except when cutting and merging MPEG2 files.

[Mr Grumpy]

I had a similar problem when I started (but happened not only with TMPG but also with CCE. Most other apps ran ok though! )

It was faulty RAM (mine was also 512MB PC2700!)

I ran MEMTEST and it highlighted some errors, so I returned the RAM to the shop (it was only a couple of months old fortunately) and they replaced it. Since then it's been fine.

I've also heard that some VIA-based mobos are a bit sensitive to 512MB DIMMs - replacing with 2 256MB DIMMs cures it (only hearsay though; mine is a single 512MB DIMM).

[fmctm1sw]

TMPGEnc is not the worst program ever!

I second that. It's called "Microsoft Excel"

[MrAndroid]

Tmpgenc can do good encoding but is slow. It's not a program that just crashes for no reason.

except when cutting and merging MPEG2 files.

I agree with that. I'm trying to encode AVI files to DVD MPEG2. Because I'm short of computer time every day I have to make shorter parts of the movie, not the whole movie at once. And when I try to merge the files, I get out of sync problem. Is ther any better alternative than TMPGenc?

Mr Android

[SatStorm]

Most of the time, those problems are solved if you learn how to frameserve.
Many users skip frameserving. This is not good...

You see, TMPGenc is very sensitive to bad/broken frames or slighty differences on framerate. Also, it hates to deal anything VBR inserted (audio/video).
By frameserving, you eliminate bad frames, audio problems, VBR (if the source is VBR, for example DVB mpeg 2 files...), so TMPGenc don't have to deal with them. In the matter of fact, if TMPGenc can't deal with them!
So, frameserve. And if your source is really bad, consider de-compress it to another avi. It needs HD, but sure eliminate all problems for good.

This is my opinion. The way I solved once and for all those problems (I use to deal with them daily, before I started frameserving anything). Maybe others know other alternatives to suggest.

[LordVader]

rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

[MrAndroid]

SatStorm: I have frameserved, that's the method I use.

[Will Hay]

Anyone who posts 'TMPGEnc is the worst program ever' and then asks for assistance is an ignorant fool.
There are thousands of people who use this across the globe without problems but incredibly it's shite because YOU can't work it properly.
At least you paid for it, I can't imagine you downloaded it for free, right?
You're the guy who's been trying to copy the 'twin towers', aren't you?
Clearly you are of the type for whom copyright means nothing, the chances of you paying for TMPGEnc are minimal and yet you insult the program because you're an idiot.
Oh, and with a heap of shit like the GA-7VAX you wonder why you have problems?
Will Hay

[FoxGarrison]

I've had troubles with TMPEGEnc, but most of the troubles was my fault. An example of this is coding a video sequence with a soundtrack that is too short...TMPEGEnc just dies.

I would have to say that TMPEGEnc is the only program I use to convert video to MPEG. It is just too powerful a program to discard. I've even made my own template. I can't say enough of just how much I love this program.

Give it a chance...try some of the suggestions you've read thus far, like create a clean system with no codecs and image the drive thereafter. It is worth the trouble!

[wway]

@Silky31

I agree that calling TMPGEnc "the worst program ever" is uncalled for.

But "ignorant fool" and "idiot" does not help the situation.


wway

[arcorob]

Tmpg is an Excellent program. I, like others here, needed some time to come to grips with it as far as setup, best methods, etc. but once we have, we have found it is truly in the top 3.

Now I realize your frustration. You are going from creating SVCD's and probably loving that, to DVD's and feel lost. So lets make it simple.

First time for the DVD's use the project wizard. It really can't be screwed up. Then when you get to OTHER SETTINGS, you can alter things to experiement but generally, the project wizard creates PERFECT DVD's.

If you are having crashes or other problems, it is not the fault of TMPG. Garbage in garbage out. so lets help you here.

What is the source material ? DVD RIP ? what is the method you used to get the source ? What do you frameserve with ?

Let us know... Rob

[Will Hay]

@Silky31

I agree that calling TMPGEnc "the worst program ever" is uncalled for.

But "ignorant fool" and "idiot" does not help the situation.


wway

Nope, you're quite right
I won't imflame the situation but it's a little annoying seeing such ignorance and trust me, I was a little reserved in typing what I actually meant.
Will

[Will Hay]

Tmpgenc can do good encoding but is slow. It's not a program that just crashes for no reason.

except when cutting and merging MPEG2 files.

Are you trying to merge mpeg2 files not created with TMPGEnc?
I've successfully merged and trimmed mpeg2 files with TMPGEnc although I wouldn't recommend many more than merging five files, I had sound issues doing that once.
Are you getting what looks like a freeze when you cut?
Will

[Gazorgan]

I've had more problems with CCE than I even had with TMPG. I don't have any problems with TMPG, VCD/SVCD or DVD encoding. I simply haven't spent the time to learn CCE, but now that I can Afford CCE, I may give it another look.

[Jason A]

I had a similar problem when I started (but happened not only with TMPG but also with CCE. Most other apps ran ok though! )

It was faulty RAM (mine was also 512MB PC2700!)

I ran MEMTEST and it highlighted some errors, so I returned the RAM to the shop (it was only a couple of months old fortunately) and they replaced it. Since then it's been fine.

I've also heard that some VIA-based mobos are a bit sensitive to 512MB DIMMs - replacing with 2 256MB DIMMs cures it (only hearsay though; mine is a single 512MB DIMM).

Same here also....

I'm running SiS chipsets but everything runs fine except Tmpge.....swapped my ram one day and TADA !!! runs great...

I think it's one of the highest quality encoders out there....it might be a bit slow, but again...tweaking it will give excellent results...

And yes...I'm a full blow registered user !!