Magical Mystery MP2

[KoalaBear]

listen to both clips before voting



Magical Mystery MP2
Geocities site down? Try this mirror instead.

[vitualis]

And blinding just went out the door...

Oh well, I don't feel so bad for potential dirtying the waters with the frequency analyses now...

Regards.

[KoalaBear]

As for you clips, I downloaded them and listened.

Good. That's all I asked you to do. But let's discuss the outcome of the experiment at its conclusion, not while it's in progress, okay?

I haven't cast my own vote yet, primarily because I don't want to see the results in advance. I'll keep it open until we have an odd number of responses above twelve, say, thirteen, fifteen, what have you, and since you've cast your vote already perhaps you can tell me when this number has been reached.

After that I'll be happy to discuss both the methodology and the result. You can wait that long, can't you, or are you trying to contaminate the data so you can self-righteously proclaim that it means nothing (which you obviously intend to do anyway)?

[vitualis]

KoalaBear, for someone who talks about "book knowledge" and "scientific method", it would really be worth your while to read on how to conduct an experiment sometime.

You labelling the clips X and Y were appropriate... You writing down which one was which here was pretty darn stupid.

As for this "poll" meaning nothing, you are absolutely correct. The only thing it had going for it was one sided blinding which you destroyed right here. If tooLame scores better than CCE it in no way means that tooLame has better audio quality than CCE and vice versa.

In effect, we've learned nothing new...

Regards.