VOTE: Tmpenc vs panasonic.

[baker]

Which do you thinks better Tmpegenc or panasonic?

HOW TO VOTE:
Simply post either: T=tmpegenc or P=Panasonic mpeg encoder

DO NOT:
Leave your signature or put anything else in the post just write T or P.

The winner will be announced soon.

Baker,

[pinoy2201]

T

[eatin sammiches for lunch]

T

[sommersby]

T

[Dhruv]

T

[tinycorkscrew]

T

[kingrdr]

T

[VCDsMakeMoney]

T



<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: VCDsMakeMoney on 2001-12-16 01:23:56 ]</font>

[lusid]

T

[neverintel]

T

[Jestorius]

T

[d4n13l]

T

[bilbogod]

T

[herokid]

T

[baker]

sadly the winner was tmpegenc.
Why do u people use tmpegenc when the quailty in panasonic is about the same and there are less blocks ?????

Please post your comments now.

Baker

[TIbrO]

TMPGEnc can be tweaked to make MPEGs that match Panasonic's MPEGs. All Panasonic does is soften block noise automatically, and doesn't let you disable it.

[Shabubu]

Unfortunately Panasonic needs an update, and TMPGEnc has it

[baker]

I am afriad that after testing using a tv out card I found that tmpegenc is a lot worse compared to panasonic than u might think. Also a new version of pwi is coming out soon. u guys should try my guide, baldwick should be posting it soon.

Baker

[Truman]

baker, it is your subjectiv opinion and that is OK. You can only compare TMPG and PWI, if you make a VCD. TMPG can do a lot more. It is simply a matter of taste, whether some one prefer PWI or TMPG.
You asked for a vote, you got it (some very experienced guys gave you the vote). Do you think, all these guys are wrong?

[sullen]

TMPGEnc is better on my wallet and is what I am now familiar with. I started on this site just as the Japanese version was released and I had to have the translator file. I started down that path because of price. I get good results so if it's not broke don't switch.

[baker]

I have to agree I understand y people say tmpegenc is better.
more options,more speed, mpeg 2 encoding E.T.C But for a standard vcd you just can't beat panasonic. Well I enjoyed this vote, I will still use panasonic of course but will on occasion use tmpegenc.

A happy with his final decision,
Baker

[Anonymous65]

Panasonic creates blurry and soft VCD's and does not have the crispness and sharpness of Tmpgenc...

[Hiei]

T

[Truman]

<TABLE BORDER=0 ALIGN=CENTER WIDTH=85%><TR><TD><font size=-1>Quote:</font><HR size=1 color=black></TD></TR><TR><TD><FONT SIZE=-1><BLOCKQUOTE>
On 2001-12-17 16:22:56, skittelsen wrote:
Panasonic creates blurry and soft VCD's and does not have the crispness and sharpness of Tmpgenc...

</BLOCKQUOTE></FONT></TD></TR><TR><TD><HR size=1 color=black></TD></TR></TABLE>
Well, but TMPG encoded MPEG look "blocky" sometimes. I never noticed that, when I used PWI. As mentioned, it's a matter of personal taste.