cloneDVD or DVD Shrink???

[eap_44]

which do you think is the best for copying DVD? some says that cloneDVD offers better quality. which do you think gives a much identical copyof the original DVD?

[soundforbjt]

CCE with DVD2SVCD gives the best quality. After that, I'd say InstantCopy.

[johns0]

Dvdshrink for copying the entire movie and cce thru dvd2svcd for putting 2 to 3 movies on dvd for me.

[bmiller]

I use anydvd with clonedvd and it works perfect everytime.Clonedvd has a much better size calculation than instant copy.With instant copy i've had movies compressed less than 20% come in under 4 gig's with instant copy,and clone dvd gives me 4.4 gig's.A much better use of available space.
I haven't tried the dvd2svcd and cce process.No need to. Much too time consuming,and clonedvd does a great job.Splitting to 2 dvd's would be a great addition.

[rhegedus]

I've found CloneDVD much easier to use than DVDshrink if you want to remove intro titles but keep the menus, especially if the DVDs have several episodes rather than a movie on them.

Whilst quality is subjective, I have no complaints about the episode DVDs I've used CloneDVD on. For straight movies with no menus, I still use DVD2ONE - it's just so easy to use.

[bmiller]

In conjunction with anydvd and clone dvd i use ifoedit and vobrator to remove fbi warnings etc.Very easy and effective