Are there *any* programs comparable to Ulead DVD Movie Factory 2 that can handle long (1+ hour) MPEG-2 sourcefiles without choking on them?
It appears that both Ulead products have a fairly naive algorithm for handling long clips that basically parses the entire clip from its starting point to the point of interest *every single time*, instead of caching a smaller chunk of the surrounding area somewhere and using *that* for frame-to-frame editing previews. The result is that trying to find the right spot to put the lead out, or pick a preview frame, or create a chapter, literally takes 20-60 seconds to recover from *any* attempt to move forward or backward by one frame, one second, or whatever.
I don't think my needs are all that demanding... basically, I have a bunch of videos on VHS that I'm capturing to 1/2 DV-1 (VBR, around 3-4mbit/sec) using ATI MMC 7.7. The general workflow is:
* rewind the tape, start the tape, tell ATI MMC to record for 2 hours, and walk away.
* do it 1 or 2 more times with additional tapes
* Use the authoring software to create a track for each captured tape
* set the lead-in and lead-out for each track to trim out the junk/noise at the start and end of each track
* for each track, set chapter points at suitable locations
* ideally (though I could live without it), spend a few minutes making a halfway decent menu page, and chapter page for each track with a thumbnail from each scene
* burn it to DVD
DVD Movie Factory 2's user interface and concept is nearly perfect. Unfortunately, the way it handles long clips makes it just about unusable. Last night I spent close to an *hour* just trying to mark the lead-out points for three tracks... (nudge) (wait 20-40 seconds) (nudge) (wait 20-40 seconds) ... (nudge) (shout unprintable vile obscenities) ...
Are there any other better alternatives in the sub-$100 price range? I looked at Nero's app, but unfortunately there's no way to test it without actually buying the MPEG-2 plugin up front. Can it do more or less the same thing, without choking on the endpoints of long files?
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 2 of 2
-
-
Well, I just did a little experiment, and discovered that DMF-2's problem lies SPECIFICALLY with VBR-encoded MPEG-2 sourcefiles. It seems to do fine with CBR.
So... I guess the updated thread topic should be, "Are there any sub-$100 authoring apps comparable to DVD Moviefactory 2 that won't choke on long VBR-encoded MPEG-2 files?"
Similar Threads
-
2 Hour Long File Conversion ffmpeg
By wsander9 in forum ffmpegX general discussionReplies: 3Last Post: 8th Oct 2011, 00:23 -
Very long AVI to mpeg
By Sparkydjm in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 2Last Post: 11th Jan 2011, 04:45 -
Mpeg Streamclip and Final Cut Pro .mpeg...Only 1 hour clips?
By checksum in forum MacReplies: 10Last Post: 16th Dec 2008, 23:38 -
Fast Computer Extremly long time Encoding
By doz in forum Video ConversionReplies: 5Last Post: 24th Apr 2008, 13:45 -
Can't get my AVIs to make a 3 hour long dvd. :(
By Nicole78 in forum Video ConversionReplies: 5Last Post: 14th Apr 2008, 15:05