When I use DVD2DVDR to record a movie to DVD-R and play it back through the Hollywood Plus player, it shows up as letterboxed on the VGA monitor mode, but when I switch over to TV mode, the black bars are gone and everything is squished in to 4:9.

I've set the player to "retain aspect ratio" and "Letterbox". I've even tried turning these off and it's still the same result. I can throw the original DVD movie into the player and the black bars show up on TV just fine.

Ideas?