Help Ripping DVD(Error)

[LCE]

Hi,
I am trying to back-up my copy of The Queen but no matter what I do I can not get it ripped.
I have tried RipIt4Me,DVDFabHD Decrypter,DVD Decrypter,AnyDVD,DVD Shrink,among others(you name it I probably used it),I also tried several in conjunction with each other and I keep getting I/O Errors (uncorrectable error,etc...)...it mostly comes up saying things like I have a scratched or dirty disc. I have cleaned the disc many times and there are no scratches.
I have tried several different drives to no advantage.
I have tried to ignore read errors and just about everything else I have read here on the boards.
The problem I believe is in the VTS_01_1.VOB file. I'm not sure if there are other problematic files or not(I think its just this one). I have tried ripping just this file by itself to no avail as well.
The movie plays great on my DVD players and on the computer I also have no problem watching,ripping,burning other DVD's on these drives.

Can anybody help me figure out just what the problem is?
Any help would be greatly Appreciated
Thank You
LCE

[NiteLite]

I've seen movies that appear to play fine but due to a minute scratch somewhere on the disc it hangs and you get an I/O error or it just stops and cant be ripped to HD.
I'd say a bad disc because my copy ripped fine using DVDFabDecrypt and the read errors are an indicator of a scratch somewhere. I have used all kinds of waxes, polishers and cleaners but sometimes the scratch is just too much for the rip to succeed. And the funny thing is I cant even find the scratch on some disc with my eyes and magnifier. Weird.
I would try another copy.
Good luck,
NL

[Krispy Kritter]

Some drives are better at reading discs (RIPPING) than others. I have an older Lite-On burner that I keep around just because it will often read discs that my Pioneer (112D) or NEC 3520/3540 won't read.

So I'd try it in another computer or with another drive if you have one.