VideoHelp Forum




+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 2 of 2
  1. Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Connecticut
    Search Comp PM
    Hi and thanks...

    If you wanted to save a FCP project as something, in case you wanted to mess with it sometime in the future (forget about the assets them selves please)....and I want to delete all the render, scratch, capture, thumbnail, auto save, etc for that project....

    What file should I export to?
    .DV FILE...? Would that be the "HIGHEST COMMON DENOMINATOR'?

    Is that better than a QuickTime .mov file?

    What is the difference between a .mov file made from:
    File, Export, QT Movie
    And
    File, Export Using QUICKTIME Compression, QuickTime Movie?

    If the answer is exporting to DV is a good choice...is it supposed to take forever to render the audio if/when I pull it back in to FCP? Why do QT's come in so quick and .dvs take a long, long time...is that part of the cost of using the "highest quality"?

    Bottom line: to archive projects/movies/ whatever (lets say 5 minutes of my kid playing soccer), and to keep it in a format other than a FCP project (cuz I need the space and want o delete stuff), what is the best export method, that allows me to grab that five minutes (oh say. a year from now) and make a "best of" DVD (or whatever) using that clip and (as an example) 20 others?

    Boy I take along time to write simple questions...sorry...sometimes it takes me an hour and a half to watch 60 Minutes (joke, ha-ha)...anyway thanks for your patience...

    Mark
    Quote Quote  
  2. Member terryj's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    N35°25.24068, W097°34.204
    Search Comp PM
    In archiving, what I do is backup the "Capture" folder where
    the media was inputed, either onto a DVD ( if it was all short clips),
    or onto a FW HD ( if the whole project's media was more than say
    2 hours). The files here are in DV/DVCPRO, wrapped in a
    Quicktime Container, so they are your highest quality files.

    FCP/FCE is based on Quicktime architecture, that is why Quicktime
    files come in the fastest. Exporting the files out to the DV Stream
    format changes the file to a DV Stream file, and FCP has to
    re-render either the audio or the video, sometimes both, to
    native Quicktime upon import to handle it.
    ( this is discussed in the FCP manual)


    as for what is the difference between File -->Export--> QT movie
    ( which is a Quicktime reference file of your Sequence,
    that contains all your edits up to this point), and File--> Export
    using Quicktime Compression-->Quicktime Movie,
    ( which is asking FCP/FCE to generate a self contained Quicktime
    movie, of your edits in the Sequence, using codecs you have
    pre-selected in Quicktime to compress the sequence down
    to your end result [MPEG-2, .mov, .mp4, etc.]), well that's
    in the Manual also....
    "Everyone has to learn, so that they can one day teach."
    ------------------------------------------------------
    When I'm not here, Where can I be found?
    Urban Mac User
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads

Visit our sponsor! Try DVDFab and backup Blu-rays!