can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD?

[dblue]

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

details

[aedipuss]

you can encode it to dvd spec, and then author it. if your encoder won't accept a ts stream, use hdtvtompeg2 to convert it into a usable file first.

[greymalkin]

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

[Cornucopia]

It probably can be used (via Ulead MF5) to be turned into a HD-DVD (on DVD-R 5 or 9). Other HD authoring solutions will follow.
Otherwise, no it can't be done -- your downrezzing!

Scott

[yoda313]

Yep you can't keep the 1080 on a standard dvd and expect it to play on a normal dvd, its outside the specs.

You can chop up the ts file and put 4gigs on a dvdr but you'll only be able to play it on a computer.

You have to downconvert it to 720x480 (ntsc) or 720x576 (pal). Otherwise a normal dvd player won't recognize.

You can demultiplex the 5.1 surround sound if it had it in the broadcast. But you must downconvert the video to play on a normal dvd player. NO way around that unless you jump up and get a bluray or hddvd burner and player.

[festmaster]

Another option is a DVD player that will recognize .ts files on DVD-R and output via HDMI. So far I have seen one at http://www.iodata.com/products/products.php?cat=HNP&sc=AVEL&pId=AVLP2%2FDVDLA&ts=2&tsc=14
I would like to see a few more models on the market before I take the plunge, but I like this idea. I would be able to have high-def captures on inexpensive red laser media, and I would be able to wait out the BluRay/ HD DVD battle.

[dblue]

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

wow, did you pick out a type-o on a forum? did you just Register here to pick out type-o's? get a life buddy

P.S. you should get a warning for spamming the forum

--------------------------

thanks you for the help guys ill post back if i have any problems

You are asked not to misuse the Report Post function; only report genuine
matters please.

/ Moderator Offline

[greymalkin]

It has nothing to do with a typo. It has everything to do with emphasizing your question (if you care to read, the first response disregarded the part I highlighted).

What I had hoped it would do is help re-emphasize the nature of your question in order to expedite a solution.

What I didn't expect it to do is tip your hormonal balance. I actually didn't even realize there was a typo in there until you had a tantrum about it.

and you're welcome.

[manono]

wow, did you pick out a type-o on a forum? did you just Register here to pick out type-o's? get a life buddy

What are you yapping about? It seemed as if you wanted to make a DVD from a 1080i file and not lose quality or resolution. We get that kind of question all the time from the uninformed. greymalkin was just gently pointing out (more gently than I am now), that it's not possible. It didn't seem then, and it doesn't seem now, to have been a typo.

[cphsrsh]

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

wow, did you pick out a type-o on a forum? did you just Register here to pick out type-o's? get a life buddy

P.S. you should get a warning for spamming the forum

--------------------------

thanks you for the help guys ill post back if i have any problems

Why don't you get a life instead of making fun of others? Besides, you don't even know the intention of that post so for you to immediately mock greymalkin seems like a very immature and foolish thing to do.

[greymalkin]

a poster (name greymalkin) samming the thread

https://forum.videohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=305189&sid=cc2acd260d4a8bdcac28a941fe90de31

I'm sorry I just couldn't help myself. The samming violation will get me kicked off for sure. Next time why don't you come to me if you have a problem with something I've posted rather than make a fool of yourself and report me for the conjurings of your imagination. If your thread is off track now it is of your own making.

I have said my share of stupid things on this forum and ticked off people for legitimate reasons, but all of my posts are available for anyone to view and you will see that I mostly just try to help in whatever capacity I can. If I'm wrong, someone smarter will come along and quickly correct me.

[manono]

Hehe, reporting this thread is liable to backfire on him, by bringing attention to the thread and by bringing a warning down on himself.

[greymalkin]

it sure did:



actually the post was edited before i could go back and take a screenshot..the original comments listed possible definitions for the word "samming"

[Baldrick]

yeye, back to the topic now.

[lordsmurf]

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

details

It can be put on DVD? Yes. A DVD is just a disc and holds any kind of data.
Can it be put into DVD-Video format, to be played on DVD-Video ("DVD") players? No.
Why? Because 1080i is not a resolution supported by the DVD-Video format

Read https://www.videohelp.com/dvd

That was the point of greymalkin's post, by the way, just in less words.

Also see https://forum.videohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=304082

[dblue]

Hehe, reporting this thread is liable to backfire on him, by bringing attention to the thread and by bringing a warning down on himself.

i dont give a dam

wow, did you pick out a type-o on a forum? did you just Register here to pick out type-o's? get a life buddy

What are you yapping about? It seemed as if you wanted to make a DVD from a 1080i file and not lose quality or resolution. We get that kind of question all the time from the uninformed.

lol uninformed? isnt this the Newbie section to get informed?

greymalkin was just gently pointing out (more gently than I am now), that it's not possible

yah, thats so obvious in greymalkin post

lets see it again.

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

it sure did:



actually the post was edited before i could go back and take a screenshot..the original comments listed possible definitions for the word "samming"

<^> figure that out

can a 1080i TS file be turned into DVD with out losing 1080i quailty?

details

It can be put on DVD? Yes. A DVD is just a disc and holds any kind of data.
Can it be put into DVD-Video format, to be played on DVD-Video ("DVD") players? No.
Why? Because 1080i is not a resolution supported by the DVD-Video format

Read https://www.videohelp.com/dvd

That was the point of greymalkin's post, by the way, just in less words.

Also see https://forum.videohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=304082

if i do make it into dvd will the Quality/resolution be better then a retail DVD?

[lordsmurf]

No.

[dblue]

No.

ok thanks