| Author |
Message |
DVantrease
Member
Joined: 08 Nov 2000
|
|
I just bought a Philips DVP-5990 DVD player, which I LOVE because now I can play divx files! Now seeing as this is NOT a BlueRay-HD player, I was wondering if it would still play HD movies (ie 720 or 1080) off a data disc or flash drive, still in high def. Although it wouldn't need the special 'blueray' laser to read the file itself, I'm just wondering if it would then play it in HD.
|
|
MJA
Member
Joined: 05 Jan 2005
Location: IL
|
|
FulciLives
UNDEAD OVERLORD
Joined: 09 May 2003
Location: Pittsburgh, PA in the USA
|
|
| MJA wrote: |
| right now I think HTPC is the best for playing HD divx |
Get a Sony PS3 ... they just reduced the price to $399.99 US Dollars for the 80GB version.
Plays HD DivX and HD XviD plus HD MP4 and M2TS files.
- John "FulciLives" Coleman
_________________
"The eyes are the first thing that you have to destroy ... because they have seen too many bad things" - Lucio Fulci
EXPLORE THE FILMS OF LUCIO FULCI - THE MAESTRO OF GORE
|
|
newnews
Member
Joined: 21 Oct 2004
|
|
Philips old DVP642 can play some high resolution videos like 800x432, but 5982,5992 won't
|
|
jman98
Member
Joined: 08 Oct 2004
Location: Freedonia
|
|
| newnews wrote: |
| Philips old DVP642 can play some high resolution videos like 800x432, but 5982,5992 won't |
Yes, BUT you have to be very careful here. As a general rule, I tell people that such players can't play anything above 720x576. If you do the math, 720 x 576 = 414720. 800 x 432 = 345600. If you multiply the resolutions and
your final result is less than 414720, it MIGHT play. However, nothing close to 720p will be less than this value. If your file barely and I do mean barely exceeds DVD specs in the horizontal resolution and the vertical resolution is less than DVD specs, then it might play, but it's just easier to tell people to not expect it to play if it's bigger than 720x576.
Note that my usual cautions on Divx playback apply to any device and things like QPel, GMC, etc. may prevent successful playback even if the device can handle the resolution OK. The original poster will definitely NOT be able to play HD Divx on his player with the exceptions noted above.
|
|
jagabo
Member
Joined: 09 Dec 2005
Location: none
|
|
Your best bet for HD Divx playback are the HD media players like the Popcorn Hour and Tvix.
|
|
jman98
Member
Joined: 08 Oct 2004
Location: Freedonia
|
|
| jagabo wrote: |
| Your best bet for HD Divx playback are the HD media players like the Popcorn Hour and Tvix. |
Yes, but they too have limits and won't "play anything". No media player yet tested, including Popcorn Hour, has been able to play Xvid/Divx using GMC with 3 warp points.
|
|
Darney76
Member
Joined: 25 Jan 2005
Location: United States
|
|
jman98
Member
Joined: 08 Oct 2004
Location: Freedonia
|
|
Darney76 - Best Buy is also selling it for $99. You might not want to wait as I got one a week ago and it was very hard to find. My metro area probably has more than a dozen Best Buy stores and I bought the next to last one available in the entire metro area. Note too that this store had it kept near the car audio section with miscellaneous gadgets, so it may be stocked in an unusual location at other Best Buy stores as well. I had to have help from a sales guy who just happened to remember seeing it in a section he didn't work in.
|
|
sdvideo
Member
Joined: 18 Nov 2008
Location: United States
|
|
whats the difference between The Western Digital WD TV HD Media Player and the xbox or PS3... other than price?
|
|
yoda313
Regular joe
Joined: 15 Jun 2004
Location: sector 001
|
|
I imagine the removable harddrives. Plus no game playing ability. And limited networking that I would know of. There is a chance this wd has a network port. However this could very well be landlocked and be for harddrives only not both. Though again this is just supposistion as I don't have one but I do have both a 360 and a ps3. Both game consoles have good networking ability without a need for a physical harddrive attached.
One other note any harddrive format like this must be in fat32 not ntfs. That means of course the 4gb file limit size comes into play. (which I can't imagine is a problem streaming to a ps3 or a 360 though I've never streamed a file that large to know of problems).
_________________
Live long and prosper - and rock on dude!!!!
|
|
MJA
Member
Joined: 05 Jan 2005
Location: IL
|
|
| yoda313 wrote: |
I imagine the removable harddrives. Plus no game playing ability. And limited networking that I would know of. There is a chance this wd has a network port. However this could very well be landlocked and be for harddrives only not both. Though again this is just supposistion as I don't have one but I do have both a 360 and a ps3. Both game consoles have good networking ability without a need for a physical harddrive attached.
One other note any harddrive format like this must be in fat32 not ntfs. That means of course the 4gb file limit size comes into play. (which I can't imagine is a problem streaming to a ps3 or a 360 though I've never streamed a file that large to know of problems). |
WD can read NTFS
|
|
stiltman
Hi Ladies
Joined: 10 Jul 2003
Location: Studio 54
|
|
| MJA wrote: |
| yoda313 wrote: |
There is a chance this wd has a network port.
One other note any harddrive format like this must be in fat32 not ntfs. |
WD can read NTFS |
no network port either
_________________
tgpo famous MAC commercial, You be the judge?
| jagabo wrote: |
| I use the FixEverythingThat'sWrongWithThisVideo() filter. Works perfectly every time. |
|
|
yoda313
Regular joe
Joined: 15 Jun 2004
Location: sector 001
|
|
@mja and stiltman - well 1/2 out ain't bad  
Did not know it supported ntfs. That is good. But I suspected it did not have a network port.
_________________
Live long and prosper - and rock on dude!!!!
|
|
sdvideo
Member
Joined: 18 Nov 2008
Location: United States
|
|
what is better at playing HD Divx, the XBOX, PS3 or WD?
|
|
MJA
Member
Joined: 05 Jan 2005
Location: IL
|
|
if money iisn't an issue,and you own a HDTV then go with the PS3
|
|
jman98
Member
Joined: 08 Oct 2004
Location: Freedonia
|
|
| MJA wrote: |
| if money iisn't an issue,and you own a HDTV then go with the PS3 |
MJA is probably right. The WD, which is the only one of the 3 that I own in sdvideo's list, is fussy about Divx. It has to be named .avi to work and others have reported having to remux files to get them to work. I can tell you that I tested it with a file that had packed bitstream and the same file only without the packed bitstream (you can remove it without re-encoding using MPEG4Modifier) and only the file without packed bitstream would play. Does the WD not like packed bitstream? I don't know. Need to do more testing. The PS3 should be a lot less fussy.
|
|
DarrellS
Member
Joined: 28 Nov 2002
Location: United States
|
|
| jman98 wrote: |
| MJA wrote: |
| if money iisn't an issue,and you own a HDTV then go with the PS3 |
MJA is probably right. The WD, which is the only one of the 3 that I own in sdvideo's list, is fussy about Divx. It has to be named .avi to work and others have reported having to remux files to get them to work. I can tell you that I tested it with a file that had packed bitstream and the same file only without the packed bitstream (you can remove it without re-encoding using MPEG4Modifier) and only the file without packed bitstream would play. Does the WD not like packed bitstream? I don't know. Need to do more testing. The PS3 should be a lot less fussy. |
All of my DivX and XviD are packed bitstream and they all play in the WD. I can only assume that it is the program used to encode the file that is causing the problem.
I had some old files a couple of years back that wouldn't play in the Philips 642 that were AVI 1.0. After direct stream copying them into an AVI 2.0 container with Virtualdub, they played fine.
If the HD-DivX (XviD) are a strange resolution then they might not play. I had some XviD files that were made with Bitmaps of different sizes and had to recode a handfull of them to a different resolution because they would not play. Files that are much larger than 1920x1080 might not play either. (A 1600x1200 file XviD plays fine but an 1800x1200 XviD file will not.
The one thing that I don't like about the WD is that a progress bar pops up at the beginning of every file and is there for about 10 seconds. It is very annoying and it isn't at the very bottom of the screen but far enough up the screen that it gets in the way of the picture. There is an option to supposedly turn it on and off but although you can make it stay on for the entire movie, you can't turn it completely off.
Money is an object for me and if it wasn't, I can't wait to see if the courts will allow Buffalo to sell their player which is probably what I'd buy and Philips doesn't seem to be interested in selling a player with the same capabilities which I'd gladly pay $150 for so the $99 WD player was perfect for me. It might not play everything out there (wish there was VC-1 support) but it will play all of my videos.
|
|
|
|
