Hi, I used to have an old TN panel (HP P201) and it's been a week since I bought a MSI G244f E2 IPS with this color gamut:
Adobe RGB / DCI-P3 / sRGB = 91% / 88% / 118%
Fisrt of all i know there are online tools for calibration, but they have given me more confusion. Here are some of them:
http://www.lagom.nl/lcd-test/
https://www.rtings.com/monitor/learn/how-to-calibrate-your-monitor-settings
http://www.photoscientia.co.uk/Gamma.htm#menu
https://www.eizo.com/library/basics/lcd_display_gamma/
Also i know that for precise adjustment I need calibration hardware, but I just want to get an approximate adjustment.
There is some modes available in the Gaming tab and the Professional tab in OSD. I noticed that some modes, in addition to changing the available settings (such as sharpening, brightness, and contrast), also seem to change inaccessible settings. For example, the first time I turned on the monitor and looked at the colors, while it looked very colorful compared to the old monitor, the colors, especially the red, were so intense that it was a little difficult to read white text on red. I tried all the modes and by activating sRGB, the colors became less saturated, and it became a bit like my old monitor and the text became more readable, while I can never repeat this by manually adjusting the colors. What I also read in RTINGS reviews is that some companies limit the color gamut range by setting the sRGB mode.
User mode (default profile):
https://freeimage.host/i/20fr2p9
sRGB mode:
https://freeimage.host/i/20frFIe
Also according to this article:
The conclusion I came to is that I use User mode when gaming and watching movies, because it provides more colors, so it makes the experience more enjoyable, but when designing and working with text and browsing the web, I prefer sRGB since it is a widely used standard.If you view this content designed for the sRGB colour space on a screen with a wider gamut than sRGB. And you aren’t controlling the gamut using one of the methods described below. Then things appear more vibrant and saturated than they should...Overly tanned or sometimes sunburnt-looking skin tones, reddish brown earth appearing far too red, yellowish green vegetation appearing overly yellow and somewhat garish...
1. So my first question is, is this true? I'm very curious to know your opinion. (Keep in mind that I feel the oversaturation of colors in movies, and since my old TN monitor made reds look yellowish, I'm used to the resulting white. I remember comparing this TN monitor to my brother's IPS monitor, I felt that my brother's monitor was orange. The white skin on the old monitor is white to me while it feels orange to me on the new monitor. So if this is a bad habit, please tell me, because even when limited to sRGB mode, this feeling is still there, although its less, so currently using custom color of 82/88/100 rgb, its something between normal and cool)
2. There are two parameters here: Gamma and Black Level, which the OSD lacks both, so I had to use the VCP codes(ClickMonitorDDC):
[Attachment 83867 - Click to enlarge]
It confuses me because in User mode and default black level (50), the colors are very saturated but in online test I can distinguish black colors from each other except 1 1 1 (in this case online tools show gamma 2.2) but if I change the black level to 51 or 52 with VCP codes, I can even see 1 1 1 (gamma will be 2.0). On the other hand in sRGB mode at default level the colors are more washed out (which is more comfortable for me), but in online test I can't distinguish between black colors from 1 1 1 to 5 5 5 (gamma is 2.2), and if I change the black level to 51 even absolute black (0 0 0) becomes gray. Finally I can use black level 50 with Night Vision in Strongest mode or Nvidia control panel, which in both cases causes gradients banding (and gamma becomes about 1.8). I don't know which gamma number to target, some people say 1.8 is better because it shows more detail than 2.2 which reduces the dark spots, and some say that since all game and movie content is produced based on 2.2 and the default settings of monitors are at 2.2, then 2.2 is better, and in the third opinion 2.0 is a sweet spot between the two. And since I want to use the two modes for two different purposes, it will be more complicated. Also I think since this IPS panel has a contrast ratio of 1000:1 so maybe that's why it can't have perfect black level, but then there shouldn't be any difference between sRGB and User, right?
Thanks in advance.
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 2 of 2
-
Last edited by amymor; 3rd Dec 2024 at 05:28.
Similar Threads
-
Black and white color on svideo
By jebaniec in forum Capturing and VCRReplies: 6Last Post: 6th Jul 2024, 09:56 -
Please help to understand color settings/profiles for DNxHR
By gs684 in forum Video ConversionReplies: 0Last Post: 20th Jan 2024, 18:47 -
1080 Color Accurate Monitor Recommendations (old models fine)
By ArcanaXIX in forum ComputerReplies: 3Last Post: 23rd Aug 2022, 20:35 -
Restore HDR Color settings in Windows 10
By forsure in forum ComputerReplies: 62Last Post: 29th Mar 2021, 18:19 -
ACER 27" 'NITRO VGO VG270 Gaming Monitor'
By cornemuse in forum ComputerReplies: 3Last Post: 19th Feb 2021, 03:39