I have just ripped a DVD which I've purchased and found a section of jerky/stuttering movement. There are other parts exhibiting a similar effect. It was particularly bad on one of my LG TVs, and can just make it out in VLC Player, but on my other LG TV, no problems, at least as far as I could see. So I'm not sure if it's a problem with the structure of the video, or just the high bitrate playing it with an external SSD drive.
I did deinterlace it with VDub Yadif and double FR, then encoded it to H264 and I "suspect " I fixed it (although I don't have immediate access to the bad TV).
Could I please have the opinions of the experts about whether there's something wrong with the file or whether it is just my TV that can't hack the pace.
Thanks a lot.
Try StreamFab Downloader and download from Netflix, Amazon, Youtube! Or Try DVDFab and copy Blu-rays! or rip iTunes movies!
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 17 of 17
Thread
-
-
I am not an expert, but at a first glance I can't find anything unusual with the file. It's just encoded as interlaced (DVD source), which may trigger the (poor?) deinterlacer of the TV?
Any particular frames which play jerky on that TV? What application did remux it to mpg? -
Yes, it's 25p frames encoded as 25i. The motion is normal for 25p. Does the attached 25p AVC video play any smoother? It should be the same.
-
Thanks Sharc, the man pauses about 3 times as he's walking right to left, only for a couple of frames-worth each time; very quick but quite noticeable and annoying (to me, at least!) on one of the TVs. I couldn't see anything wrong stepping through the video in AVIDemux; VDub2 shows ugly grey frames/blotches, but it seems to do that with many MPEGs.
I used DVDShrink to rip it (no compression) to a single large VOB and AVIDemux to lossless-copy the VOB to MPG. -
I streamed it to my TV and it plays as smooth as silk ....... (well, as much as you can expect from 25fps). So nothing unusual.
Last edited by Sharc; 12th Mar 2023 at 08:10.
-
Originally Posted by Jagabo
My AVIDemux technique doesn't work with my double frame rate effort; too many frames to pick the pausing.
Thanks Sharc, as mentioned, it is quite noticeable on only one TV which was the one I was watching on holiday. Perhaps it was the TV deinterlacer. -
-
@Jabago, fair enough.
I won't have access to the problem TV for a few weeks so I'll have to bide my time. I'll definitely take all these variations to try though.
Out of interest, what was your technique for converting back that video back to Progressive? I ended up doing the whole video, as there were other parts with the same pausing. -
-
What was that Tv's monitor refresh rate? 60Hz? Has it been forced to 24Hz (film mode or similar)? If the monitor refresh rate is not an integer multiple of the video framerate one will see some judder.
-
@Sharc, It's a bog-standard TV, field refresh rate 100hz, not adjustable AFAIK.
@Jagabo, what technique do you use to determine it's Progressive? I'm curious for next time. -
Separating the fields, and stepping through the fields. See for example here:
https://forum.videohelp.com/threads/407467-Vhs-capture-advice/page13#post2682974
It can also been done in VirtualDub:
https://forum.videohelp.com/threads/407467-Vhs-capture-advice/page14#post2683048 -
-
You don't need to separate fields in this case. Just open the video and look at the frames. There are no interlace comb artifacts where there is motion. So it's progressive.
Similar Threads
-
MP4 stuttering on new system
By akkers in forum Software PlayingReplies: 2Last Post: 22nd Feb 2023, 08:37 -
Video Stuttering Issue
By joebor5000 in forum Blu-ray RippingReplies: 22Last Post: 18th Jan 2023, 21:34 -
Stuttering video
By masster in forum RestorationReplies: 3Last Post: 22nd Aug 2021, 00:28 -
interlaced conversion stuttering
By fullhdfan in forum Video ConversionReplies: 3Last Post: 23rd Mar 2020, 14:58 -
playback stuttering in vdub
By Ryan88 in forum CapturingReplies: 0Last Post: 23rd Aug 2019, 12:28