VideoHelp Forum



Support our site by donate $5 directly to us Thanks!!!

Try StreamFab Downloader and download streaming video from Netflix, Amazon!



+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 7 of 7
  1. Is there a way to download the YT auto generated subtitles as a separate text file?
    Will YT auto generate subtitles in a foreign language on a foreign language film?
    Or auto convert to English?

    What I really want is to translate foreign language films into English when there are no subtitles available anywhere. YT may help. I could upload the video.
    I want to get a text file of the speech from a foreign language film in that language. Then I can use Google translate to get into English.

    Ideas?
    Quote Quote  
  2. Is there a way to download the YT auto generated subtitles as a separate text file?
    Yes, you can use yt-dlp program which has essential subtitle options.

    Examples:
    Code:
    # this will download all auto-generated subtitles by youtube
    yt-dlp LINK --write-auto-subs --sub-langs "all"
    
    # this will download only official subtitles added by creator
    yt-dlp LINK --write-subs
    Will YT auto generate subtitles in a foreign language on a foreign language film?
    Or auto convert to English?
    It will vary on Creator and YouTube itself. More Information

    I want to get a text file of the speech from a foreign language film in that language. Then I can use Google translate to get into English.
    You can use YouTube but there is no guarantee and quality might not be optimum. It's better you try searching the title on OTT platforms, Bluray, etc. sources to see if there are any official subtitle from creators themselves. I would also search on machine-learning/ai related community to see if there are any accessible project which can help me with the auto subtitle.
    Quote Quote  
  3. Thanks. I will try these. My thinking is that Google has the money to make their auto-generated subtitles work. But they do have a 10%-25% error rate on English films. No idea how well Foreign languages will do. If I can get 50% accurate, I will be satisfied. Better than nothing. I can get the overall idea.

    The web sites and programs I see are all too expensive. If I only ever wanted to do one movie, they would be OK. I have looked but can't find any communities for transcribing ai discussions.
    Quote Quote  
  4. Yes. It works. Thank you. I uploaded a video and was able to get YT to create the subtitles in the original language. Then you can get auto translate to another language while you play. And yt-dlp can download the subtitle files. The speech detection is poor but it gets over 50% of the words correct on my quick test. The auto English translation kinda sucks. It will display a translation for one person but not when the other person speaks. Even though the video has original language subtitles for that other person. Odd.
    I am not clear on what steps are needed to auto generate the subtitles. I think I am doing extra steps that I don't have to. It takes a while. Maybe an hour to create subtitles for a 10 minute video.
    Quote Quote  
  5. Originally Posted by ChasVideo View Post
    Is there a way to download the YT auto generated subtitles as a separate text file?
    Will YT auto generate subtitles in a foreign language on a foreign language film?
    Or auto convert to English?

    What I really want is to translate foreign language films into English when there are no subtitles available anywhere. YT may help. I could upload the video.
    I want to get a text file of the speech from a foreign language film in that language. Then I can use Google translate to get into English.

    Ideas?
    Which languages are the movies originally? I have used Adobe Premiere which uses AI/machine learning. Found it to work pretty well. Has these languages English, English UK, simplified Chinese, Traditional Chinese, Spanish, German, French, Japanese, Portuguese, Korean, Italian, Russian, and Hindi.

    And for languages not in the above list, I've used descript. I have created subtitles in Polish, Slovakian, and Czech Republic. Again worked pretty well with pretty high accuracy. This is a paid for software but you can get a free trial of about 3 hours of subtitle transcribing.

    Both programs can export the subtitles in srt and other formats.
    Last edited by Jawz22; 13th Jul 2022 at 16:25. Reason: more info
    Quote Quote  
  6. Originally Posted by Jawz22 View Post
    Which languages are the movies originally? I have used Adobe Premiere which uses AI/machine learning. Found it to work pretty well. Has these languages English, English UK, simplified Chinese, Traditional Chinese, Spanish, German, French, Japanese, Portuguese, Korean, Italian, Russian, and Hindi.

    And for languages not in the above list, I've used descript. I have created subtitles in Polish, Slovakian, and Czech Republic. Again worked pretty well with pretty high accuracy. This is a paid for software but you can get a free trial of about 3 hours of subtitle transcribing.

    Both programs can export the subtitles in srt and other formats.
    Yes. These sound like the correct idea. Thank You. I searched for speech to subtitle programs/services and only found kinda expensive ones. They give limited hours per month before charging extra. I had no idea Premiere can do this now. I used Premiere in the past. I don't like the monthly subscription service but Premiere and descript having a monthly plan actually works for me. I can do all the movies I need to do within one month.

    Question: Does descript actually use human transcribers? It sort of sounds like that. It says "Automatic and human-powered transcription with industry leading accuracy and powerful collaboration tools." You submit your audio/video and they return it later. But the price is too low so maybe it is just ai software. That means you have to upload and download at least the audio portion. I prefer to do it locally. I will try Premiere first.
    Last edited by ChasVideo; 14th Jul 2022 at 02:56.
    Quote Quote  
  7. Question: Does descript actually use human transcribers? It sort of sounds like that. It says "Automatic and human-powered transcription with industry leading accuracy and powerful collaboration tools." You submit your audio/video and they return it later. But the price is too low so maybe it is just ai software. That means you have to upload and download at least the audio portion. I prefer to do it locally. I will try Premiere first.
    They may do it that way, but I upload my video and then transcribe the subtitles online an then download the .srt file. So I guess it is an AI software.
    Last edited by Jawz22; 14th Jul 2022 at 10:25.
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads

Visit our sponsor! Try DVDFab and backup Blu-rays!