My vote is power supply, whenever I have seen any system that would randomly crash, it was nearly always a power supply going bad.
But i must say, what the OP is doing with the ram is insane, it seems like he is installing the 16gb sticks in the wrong slots, i.e. side by side instead of alternating slots.
In order for ram to run in dual channel mode, it needs to be installed in every other slot, but this guy seems to have installed the 2x16gb sticks in slots right next to each other and then he added an 8gb stick in the 3rd slot.
He doesn't seem to realize that what he has done is slowed his system down, assuming he hasn't affected the stability. Unless he's using apps that go past the 32gb barrier, 2x16gn sticks in dual channel mode are going to be faster that 2x16gb+1x8gb sticks in single channel mode.
+ Reply to Thread
Results 31 to 55 of 55
2. the games that were crashing were started recently, ive played at least 5 games since the new ram and gpu were installed
3. no other changes
4. yes but it was all stable until a month or 2 ago
Pc's will load up even if the ram is side by side but will lose the dual channel mode,have you tried running just the single 8 gb ram stick to see if it still crashes?I think,therefore i am a hamster.
i tried the ram in side by side slots and the pc didnt load, i will be trying each ram stick in each slot to see if it crashes or not, but that could take weeks
Just try the 8gb ram in a slot that will load up.I think,therefore i am a hamster.
Ok. The answers are useful but you have still elaborated.
7. Do these 'new' games play just with the old memory and no other issues.
8. Does the system still crash simply by running Firefox (as before)
I guess that the old memory is no longer installed but from a diagnostic perspective it is useful to see 'what if' I only had that. Also if you read the topic I linked to my own issues were based on the fact that the different memory had different timings and the slower memory killed the system that was booted by the faster memory. The solution, for me, was to swap the sticks and boot from the slower memory. The one difference in my case that I have 4 sticks installed.
Yes. I am still focused on the memory but I do recall my dad's PC having PSU issues and, unfortunately, there is only one solution in that scenario.
But before I turn in.
9. Is your GPU receiving adequate power ?
7. i dont know the new ram has been in since nov but other games have played without crashes
8. if you mean does it crash when i start firefox then no that might have just been a coincidence
9. yes the psu is 850 w and there is 8 slots that are filled by the power supply
everyone is blaming the ram or blaming me saying ive not got the ram in the right slots but it was all running fine since nov, every test ive done has been ok, im still thinking it might be the psu but i started this for other options just to check things out and it didnt behave like the last psu that was faulty, but i have a 750w psu in another pc that hasnt been used as much so if it crashes again in the next few days/weeks while gaming or not, ill put that in and try it for a few weeks and see what happens
out of interest ive also ran tests on the ssd's and they are all fine
Last edited by adamf154; 20th Apr 2021 at 18:00.
Trouble is that you now contradict the answers to the Q.'s
Now you state you had issues >> crashes upon loading. So things have not has been as 'rosey' as you have made them out to be.
I did not ask how many of the PSU slots were occupied. I asked if your GPU is receiving adequate power. My GPU has a power socket. It is not occupied yet I would imagine that if I was using the card to it's potential it requires power.
But, equally, overload the PSU and you create problems.
im not contradicting myself if you read it properly you will see that i have had psu problems before and it crashed when a game started, you seriously dont think that, that is the same psu, if it was crashing when a game loaded i wouldnt be able to play any games just now and i did state its not acting like the last faulty psu i had when it crashed upon loading a game
no you didnt ask how many slots were occupied but i told you anyway, so you couldnt blame the gpu or me for there not being enough power, on one hand i can play a game for a few hours before it crashes and that could overload it, on the other hand it has crashed with very litttle being done on the pc
like i say im going to try my other psu if it crashes again and ill know if the other one doesnt crash when im playing a game or doesnt just crash for weeks then ill buy a new psu, it could just be after 2 years its starting to fail, i hoped i would get longer out of it, its an arctic blue 850w but ill not be buying that make again if this is faulty already, im not sure if the more expensive ones are any better and last longer than what i have
A psu is only as good as it has enough amperage to power up devices,is your psu a quality make such as seasonic,corsair or evga?I think,therefore i am a hamster.
ram is 2x16gb in first 2 slots and an 8gb in one of the other slots
i tried the ram in side by side slots and the pc didnt load
After this revelation, I think it may be your motherboard.
One question, why did you decide to add an additional 8gb stick to the 32gb you already have? Also, is all the ram dual bank, single bank or a combination?
It is unclear to me if your whole pc crashes (in the since of complete failure, cut out or blue screens)
Or is it just a application (your game in this case) that crashes and just that application cuts out
In last case i would blame the game, but a combo of cpu/ram could also be possible
In the first case i would suspect the whole hardware and it could be many things. I would start with memtest and let it run overnight and let it test all of your ram.
If that is ok do a stresstest with prime95 https://www.mersenne.org/download/ But make sure that your cpu cooling is functioning at full capacity!
If that passes without any faults a hardware faillure is not very likely
Some years ago i worked in a computer repair store, we always used the same procedure to pin down such problems.
Mem test and some other tests (you can use usb stick instead of cd):
That said, if it was a software problem, it would most likely cause a bluescreen and collect a dump instead of just turn off. Also memory related stuff typically caused more a bluescreen than turn off.
Turning off was mostly caused by overheated CPU, e.g. after some years operation, the cpu fan collected so much dust inside the motor that it got a little bit harder to turn as if it was new, causing less colling. Memory faults was next (they were always detected using memtest) but these days they are far less common than 10 years ago. If that was not the case, changing the psu typically solved it. Last but not least in some really rare cases, we needed to change the mainboard, like in 1 o 1000 cases.
ive ran memtest then i ran prime95 overnight and there were no problems with either, but i was running occt on the power check and the pc restarted, so i done it again and the pc restarted again, so im thinking as i first thought its probably the psu, so im going to put another one in from my other pc and see how that runs with occt and playing games and if it all works fine ill have a definitive answer, ive decided not to buy the same one again an artic blue 850w, ill try a different make cause this one isnt 2 years old yet and im not gaming everyday and every night or doing anything that would put alot of stress on the pc, so im thinking it should be lasting longer
well that didnt work, effing grahpics card needs 8 pins and doesnt work with 6, and my other psu only has a 6 pin so it didnt work at all and ryzen doesnt have onboard graphics looks like im going to have to buy a new psu whether i like it or not and whether its a psu problem or not, or i might get a 6 pin to 8 pin extension (been some bad reviews about them burning and starting a fire so unsure whether to get one or not or to just get a new psu) and at least i can get it checked with a different psu
Last edited by adamf154; 22nd Apr 2021 at 10:31.
There's usually a separate 2 pin plug that can be added with the 6 pin plug,if not then the psu isn't that good.I think,therefore i am a hamster.
so i finally got round to buying a new psu, but i wish id just kept the old one, as the games are still crashing with the new psu, one game is crashing everytime i put it on and start to play and the other game doesnt crash so quick but took over an hour before it crashed
so i ran all the stress tests before and the only thing that crashed the pc was occt, so my plan now is to check both games out on my other pc, the minimum reqs for both games are am3 cpus, so my other cpu is also am4, it might not be pretty but it will let me see if it is crashing on that pc, i will also then use my old graphics card which should just be able to play the games aswell and see if there is any crashing, if not i will put the ryzen 7 on that motherboard and then try it and see and then eventually ill put the newer graphics card on and that should tell me if there is any problems and i will also try another game on this pc and see if that crashes at any point
i done that when they first crashed, both games have reported crashes and other stuff, but im not sure if they have been restarting the whole pc or just crashing to desktop for others, i thought it might have been the games when i was having problems a few weeks ago but thought both games crashing the exact same way is prob some kind of hardware problem but my mind turned to "it could def be the games", earlier when it crashed first time back trying the games with a new psu but im going to do what i typed above with the other pc over the weekend, and ill try a different game on this pc and if that crashes, then it has to be a hardware prob, so hopefully ill will have some kind of definitive answer by the end of the weekend
Why do you not simply answer the Q's raised ?
The question was "What games are you playing"
But, again, this is a red herring given that you earlier stated that a simple invocation of a web browser caused a system crash. No games running then. Yes or No ?
Sorry but you are still throwing dice. You are not doing an orderly diagnostic process by blaming software over hardware. Ask your self just why OCCT, by way of your latest info, crashes. Does that not provide you with a log that highlights the point of the crash ?
i think occt only produces an output file if you pay for the professional version, im only using the free version but i will try that again over the weekend with the new power supply and see if it still crashes
event logs are error 41 and just says the system had rebooted without cleanly shutting down first, this error could be caused if the system stopped responding, crashed or lost power unexpextedly
occt has just crashed again on the power section, after about 30 mins, im going to change over the graphics card and see if everything still crashes before i start messing around checking stuff on the other pc
so i changed the graphics card, and i have been playing one of the games for the last hour without any problem, so it must the be the graphics card that is faulty and causing the games to crash, and that pisses me off as its only 6 months old, ill do some checks with occt aswell and just see what happens