VideoHelp Forum

Try DVDFab and copy Ultra HD Blu-rays and DVDs! Or rip iTunes movies and music! Download free trial !
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 5 of 5
Thread
  1. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    India
    Search Comp PM
    Though the following topics were discussed in this forum, I have doubts about these now and then. So, I want to get it cleared once for all.

    1) Video of any format will lose its quality when it is re-encoded even if the video bit rate is increased. To put it in detail, a video is decoded to lossless format, increased the video bit rate and re-encoded to the same format or different format, re-sized to higher resolution. By doing so, the quality can't be enhanced.

    2) Similarly, audio file is converted to wave format and re-converted to same or different format increasing the bit rate. Even then, the quality of the audio can't be enhanced.

    I think I have made my doubts clear. Appreciate comments.
    Quote Quote  
  2. Originally Posted by shans View Post
    Though the following topics were discussed in this forum, I have doubts about these now and then. So, I want to get it cleared once for all.

    1) Video of any format will lose its quality when it is re-encoded even if the video bit rate is increased. To put it in detail, a video is decoded to lossless format, increased the video bit rate and re-encoded to the same format or different format, re-sized to higher resolution. By doing so, the quality can't be enhanced.

    2) Similarly, audio file is converted to wave format and re-converted to same or different format increasing the bit rate. Even then, the quality of the audio can't be enhanced.

    I think I have made my doubts clear. Appreciate comments.

    Yes - compression wise - you cannot objectively increase the "quality" compared to the original for audio or video . You cannot get better than what you started with, no matter the bitrate, no matter lossless or lossy


    But you can subjectively increase the quality by performing other operations or filtering. E.g. if video is blurry you can sharpen. If video is too dark , you can brighten etc... If video is too noisy, you can denoise it. If speech frequencies are too low, you can enhance them etc... You might be able to subjectively do a better job of upscaling than your software or hardware player.

    "Quality" is a difficult thing to describe or measure, but objectively, by metrics, you cannot get better than you started with
    Quote Quote  
  3. Member Cornucopia's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2001
    Location
    Deep in the Heart of Texas
    Search PM
    To add to what pdr said:
    You can increase certain aspects of the signal, in order to get a result that is subjectively improved for the target audience, but this does come at a cost, and other things might/will decrease in the result, quality-wise. Brightness might increase, but overall dynamic range may decrease as a result. Or, perceived sharpness might increase, but noise & halos might increase as well (making it harder to compress).

    After "creation" or capture, it's always a level or downhill progression in overall quality. Which is why you want to start with the very best possible, and do as little damage as possible.

    Note: there are lossless and lossy (compression) FORMATS and there are lossless and lossy PROCESSES. You want to manage both sets to arrive at minimal loss overall.


    Scott
    Quote Quote  
  4. There is an exception to the "will lose its quality when it is re-encoded" rule: when using lossless codecs. The losses video will be exactly the same quality as the source. The problems is that lossless codecs (huffyuv, lagarith, UT video codec, x264 lossless, etc.) are very inefficient compared to the lossy codecs (MPEG 2, h.264, h.265, etc.). If you start with a lossy compressed video and recompress it with a lossless codec your final file will likely be 10 or more times larger. So it's a waste of time unless you have some special need (like an editor that can't handle your lossy compressed source).
    Quote Quote  
  5. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    India
    Search Comp PM
    Yes, I understood that it is very difficult to define the quality precisely under various scenarios. Thanks @poisondeathray @Scott @ jagabo
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads