here is screen shots from my American pie 2 blu-ray
Edited Colors In VLC Player Looks Much Better
so why such dull and dark colors ?
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 12 of 12
I suspect it mostly depends on the player. Or if from a hardware DVD/BD set top player, the TV or monitor settings.
With a computer, there are plenty of settings available with the video card.
And I suspect many TVs or monitors have never been set up properly as they have quite a few settings also.
Then finally there is personal preference.
For example, I find most laptops have the brightness turned up close to max.
I guess that is what the manufacturer thinks is correct. I have my own idea of what is correct.
Most of us have spent a fair amount of time trying to get our playback systems the way we want them.
Anyway, I would just make your video playback settings the way you want and damn everyone else!!!
End of rant...
Normally your HDTV takes the video input and pumps ups the saturation, contrast, and brightness. So maybe the people who encoded the bluray are just anticipating that.
Are these snapshots directly from a bluray source or an encoding?
I'm not familiar with Western releases since I rarely watch, much less purchase them, but the majority of Asian releases (Japanese, Korean, Hong Kong, Taiwan), I watch have very good transfers. Japan in particular, has historically always put extra care into their video transfers going back to least to their Laserdisc releases.
As for American Pie 2, this review of the Blu-Ray http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/American-Pie-2-Blu-ray/30440/#Review confirms that the transfer was poorly done:
"The VC-1 encoded image (1.85:1 aspect ratio) presentation carries a certain age, lacking a recent scan that could pull out a little more freshness to an 11-year-old film. The viewing experience is slightly off, presenting a darker image with a muted color palette, bringing down the youthful energy of the movie. Skintones vary, looking unnatural at times, drained of life. Shadow detail is on the solid side, with limited clarity when approaching dense fabrics, hairstyles, and low-lit distances. Fine detail is acceptable but never extraordinary, good with facial textures and some beachgoing shenanigans. While certainly a step up from the previous DVD release, "American Pie 2" doesn't make a bold impression on BD, lacking the flat, crisp sense of colorful cartoonish mayhem it was meant to have."
My guess is that release was low budget / priority given the intended market, i.e. anyone who bought American Pie wouild likely buy American Pie 2 no matter the disc quality.
The nice thing about many Western Blu-Ray/DVD releases is that they're usually reviewed prior to or immediately after release (blu-ray.com and dvdbeaver.com being two popular sites), so you'll have time to decide on your purchase, unless you really want that Limited First Edition Extended [edit: Boxed] release.
Last edited by lingyi; 11th May 2016 at 01:26.
maybe it is just the standard settings on your PC, that make it look so dark
just set your favorite player to the brightness level you prefer
That second shot looks like overcooked crap, too.
Contrast is not accurate.
Black levels terrible.
The big issue is lazy video releases. That is is one of my biggest pet peeves.
Sad but true:
A lot of videographers/encoders/etc working in the field have no real training or knowledge. It's a ugly shift from the 90s and even the 00s. So you get a lot of inept stooges that are not qualified. As a result, they often screw stuff up.
And as I've mentioned before, several releasers quit sending me Blu-rays to review. Why? Because they were technically awful, worse than the DVDs. I'm not exaggerating. So rather than listen to feedback, heed reviews -- they decided they didn't want me to review anything. All they wanted were lemmings with fluff "reviews" to say how great it was. Screw 'em. This is a huge reason I rarely buy Blu-ray releases.
Most movies look dull and dark cause you haven't set your tv/monitor properly.I think,therefore i am a hamster.
Or not. If you don't understand the reasoning behind studio levels, don't embarrass yourself by throwing in "medieval".
OP: Question #1 should be - have you calibrated you displays?
And make sure your display looks like the second image in the post.
And, as KarMa pointed out, TVs are usually set up to pump up the contrast and saturation because that's what people like, not because it's the way the video is supposed to look.
Last edited by jagabo; 15th May 2016 at 13:10.
Studio levels are not related to any display technology. They are related to the process of digitizing analog signals.
And unless you screwed up something studio levels are not a reason for dull colors. At all.