Which video capture method would you recommend

[rysktkr]

Hi

I have two alternatives for capturing my 8mm home videos and was wondering which method would yield the best video capture.
1) ATI All-in-wonder
2) Honestech Vidbox via usb Virtualdub HuffyUV

[Snakebyte1]

Video quality is often a very subjective matter. What one person may find acceptable another might consider crap. What method works best for one person may not work best for another, and what works on one tape may not be the best for another.

In short, if you have multiple means available to you, try them, do some experiments with the settings etc and then use whatever you determine to be the best results for you.

[edDV]

Which All-In-Wonder?

If Huffyuv is the goal, I'd vote for All-In-Wonder hardware over any USB device.