WD Live Media Player vs Roku HD Media Player

[marionr26]

I know the WD Live HD Player can play files from your portable HD connected to it. I think it also plays Netflix,youtube,Hulu. The Roku Player plays netflix,Hulu,Youtube also but you cant hook a portable HD to it and play computer downloads I dont think. So what is the better player you think the WD Live ???? I was thinking of getting one or the other for xmas just want some Pro's and Con's of each Please reply.........Thanks http://www.wdc.com/en/products/products.aspx?id=330 http://www.roku.com/roku-products I would prob get a Blu Ray Player but I want to also play Hulu or Hulu Plus these have it and alot of Blu Ray players dont have it

[Baldrick]

Please do not cross post. Even if the thread fits in several forum sections.