Mp3 player dilemma

[alintatoc]

I want to buy an mp3 player but I have 3 in my mind, what do you recommend from the 3:

Creative ZEN X-Fi2 8GB
Creative ZEN X-Fi 16GB
Sony NWZS545B S Series 16GB

[yoda313]

Hmmm.... Do they have a xfi2 in the 16gb model? I don't know what it can and can't do but all I can say is:

GET AS MUCH STORAGE SPACE AS YOU CAN AFFORD COMFORTABLY!

Unless it has an expansion slot for an sd card or memory stick you'll be stuck at that size. So make sure you get as much room as you can.

NOW on the other hand if you are only interested in music and don't need lossless or lossy codecs then you don't need as much space. If you're not going to be loading lots of video than you won't need quite as much space.