Hi All.
I need to select components for my pc based on the monitor which is going to be used. It has a native resolution of 1920 x 1200 and has 1 x VGA, 1 x DVI-D and 1 x HDMI ports. I will running two of these monitors in a dual monitor setup. I would like video playback to be the best quality possible. Most video will be downloaded from the Internet or streamed. I would like the pc to be able to handle the occasional game, but this is not as important as the video. I also would like it to be as future proof as possible, so I don't mind buying components which may seem to be overkill for my needs now, but may come in handy later on, as I do not upgrade too often.
I have taken a look at the HTPC boards here and elsewhere and am not sure if they apply to me as it's not really going to be a 'Home Theatre' pc. I just want good quality video playback.
The OS will be Linux (probably Ubuntu) and the processor will be AMD.
Is there anything in particular which I need to look out for in a motherboard?
Most importantly, any suggestions for a graphics card to suit my needs would be greatly appreciated. I am not sure if it's true or not, but I get the impression from browsing various forums that ATI graphics cards tend to be problematic with Linux.
Thanks for any help or advice!
Try StreamFab Downloader and download from Netflix, Amazon, Youtube! Or Try DVDFab and copy Blu-rays! or rip iTunes movies!
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 18 of 18
Thread
-
-
A US$500 card won't get you any better video quality than a US$100 card. A Nvidia GTX 260 based card with dual DVI output will run you around US$200. That will be sufficient for gaming.
-
Thanks jagabo.
So can HD be viewed with any graphics card? It doesn't need to have any features about HD?
Just for information, if gaming wasn't an issue, what would you have recommended then?
Thanks. -
Originally Posted by A Traveller
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VDPAU
Any modern GPU will display Movies with great quality. The limiting factor for quality movie playback comes down to the quality of the display device (Your Monitor), and the playback application. I have a lowly nVidia 9400, supports VDPAU, which displays 1920x1080 H.264 high def material while using ~10% CPU power. It doesn't game for crap though
With the GTX 260, you'll get the best of both worlds. Hardware acceleration for video decoding, and one hell of a powerful gaming GPU.Linux _is_ user-friendly. It is not ignorant-friendly and idiot-friendly. -
Thanks for that extremely helpful post.
I've taken a look at the 260 card and noticed that some cards were called 'GTX 260-2' and some were just 'GTX 260'. What is the difference between the two?
There are also many brands available - Zotac, BFG, XFX, Sparkle, Palit, MSI, Sapphire. Is there any particular one that I should consider (or avoid)? Looks like the MSI one is a bit too expensive.
I've also come across another card called the GeForce 8800 GT, which seem to have gotten good reviews. Does the 8800 GT also have everything that you have suggested? I can't seem to tell because both cards have better specifications in different areas. Which one would be best for my needs, considering what you suggested, such as Linux support, VDPAU, etc? I think they're both going to cost the same amount anyway.
(CLICK THE SPECIFICATION TAB)
http://www.nvidia.com/object/product_geforce_gtx_260_us.html
http://www.nvidia.com/object/product_geforce_8800_gt_us.html
Thanks again! -
Not all 8800's support VDPAU. A 9800 or the GTX 260 series would be your best bet for gaming.
According the links you posted, the GTX 260 offers quite a bit more muscle than the 8800.
8800 vs GTX 260
Processor Cores 112 192
Graphics Clock (MHz) 600 MHz 576 MHz
Processor Clock (MHz) 1500 MHz 1242 MHz
Texture Fill Rate (billion/sec) 33.6 36.9
Memory Clock (MHz) 900 MHz 999 MHz
Standard Memory Config 512 MB 896 MB
Memory Interface Width 256-bit 448-bit
Memory Bandwidth (GB/sec) 57.6 111.9
It's not who fast the Clock runs, it's what the GPU can do in those ticks that matters. The GTX 260 has a higher fill rate, and much greater memory bandwidth.
The brands would matter like Pepsi vs. Coca Cola vs R.C. It's more a matter of taste than anything. Only a slight few are cheap crap. Most manufacturers happen to make quality products. I currently own 6 eVGA cards, never an issue with any of them. That doesn't mean much, as I have not had the opportunity to own enough other makes to make a solid comparison.
BFG, PNY, Gigabyte, eVGA are known good manufacturers. There are others, but those come to mind. Sparkle seems popular, but I believe it's more from a price point, than a quality point.Linux _is_ user-friendly. It is not ignorant-friendly and idiot-friendly. -
Ok, thanks again for all your helpful advice. I really appreciate it!
Unfortunately, since you have been so helpful, I'm going to take advantage of that (haha) and ask if you have any advice on the motherboard side of things. What features do I need to ensure that the motherboard have to make the most of my setup (or ensure that it is at least compatible!!!!)? Are there any motherboards available that are known to be friendly with Linux (Ubuntu)?
Do I need to ask the manufacturer of the monitors if they have drivers for Linux, or do monitors normally work automatically anyway?
Lalstly, am I correct in thinking that nowadays I don't need to worry about the motherboard or soundcard having an SPDIF out as the single cable does it all?
It's going to be an entirely new pc, so any advice on hardware BEFORE I buy the parts would be a huge comfort.
Thanks again, and sorry for the extra questions. -
Originally Posted by A Traveller
Do I need to ask the manufacturer of the monitors if they have drivers for Linux, or do monitors normally work automatically anyway?
Lalstly, am I correct in thinking that nowadays I don't need to worry about the motherboard or soundcard having an SPDIF out as the single cable does it all?
It's going to be an entirely new pc, so any advice on hardware BEFORE I buy the parts would be a huge comfort.
Thanks again, and sorry for the extra questions.Linux _is_ user-friendly. It is not ignorant-friendly and idiot-friendly. -
Thanks for all that, disturbed1.
(Yes, it was sound over HDMI that I was referring to.)
Hope all goes well! -
I haven't seen any graphics cards with two HDMI outputs. You're going to be using DVI outputs so there will be no sound (DVI can carry audio multiplexed with the video but I haven't seen any devices that actually use it). You will probably end up running sound to your monitor/reciever/speakers separately.
-
Ok jagabo. Thanks for clarifying. Yes, I will only be listening to the sound on my pc speakers, not the monitor's speakers.
-
It's me again!
I have now bought the monitors, as you may already know (HG281D).
The graphics card that they have been connected to is an old GeForce 3 Ti200 (64Mb). I did not know that this card had a DVI port. It was only in the process of connecting the monitors, that I discovered it. So, it has one DVI and one VGA. Can I connect both monitors to my pc at the same time, one via DVI and one via VGA? I haven't tried it as I don't want to damage anything!
I am still planning on buying a card with 2 DVI's as suggested here as I want both to have good quality connections. I am, however, curious to know, would there be ANY difference at all in video playback/quality or images between the GTX 260 and the card mentioned above? I have looked on the website linked to here but could not see that the Ti200 had VDPAU. If this can be done, will the graphics card properties automatically include options to rotate one monitor, or can does the card have to be a special "dual monitor" card?
I tried downloading an HD clip from the Internet. It was about 75Mb for about 3 minutes of video. The first five or so seconds, played fine, but after that it was just like watching a slideshow of still images, no sort of motion. I also played a game from about ten years ago and it had a slight jerkiness to it, unlike on my 17" (15") CRT. Any possible reasons for these two issues? I reduced the window size from within the game, however, that didn't make any difference. As mentioned before, it's the video playback that is most important, so I don't mind if game related things aren't 100% perfect, but it would be nice! Haha.
Thanks. -
Geforce 3 Ti 200 is pretty old. It definitely does not have CUDA/DXVA/VDPAU. I don't think it has dual monitor support. Try hooking both monitors up and see if the setup applet will let you set up dual monitors. Same with rotation. Just try it.
Are you really running a 700 MHz CPU? That would explain the jerky playback of HD video. The old graphics card would explain the low frame rate on games. Slow GPU + high resolution = slow rendering. -
Thanks again jagabo.
It's slightly more than 700MHz, Haha!
Ok, so when I purchase all this brand new expensive gear and am ready to go in terms of high quality video playback, what would be the best way to ensure that I can still watch my current low quality video and all the other normal/low quality video that you come across everyday on websites, such as AVI, MPEG, WMV and FLV? Is it just a case of reducing the size of the player's window until the video is watchable?
disturbed1 mentioned the requirement of a quality 'playback application'. Is GOM Player one of those?
Thanks. -
Linux _is_ user-friendly. It is not ignorant-friendly and idiot-friendly.
-
Hi disturbed1.
Yes, sorry, I haven't started using Linux fully yet. I'm still at the stage where I'm looking for compatible hardware.
I'll re-post the low quality part on the appropriate board. Thanks for alerting me about going off track. I tend to get so involved in my problems and sorting them that I forget where I am and what I'm doing!!
Thanks everyone for all the help received in this thread. It has been most helpful!! -
No player is going to make low quality videos look like high quality sources. Some things can be adjusted like black level, tint/saturation, aspect ratio problems, deblocking, and a little sharpening.
Similar Threads
-
Re using old Sonic hardware - little help?
By Pentos in forum CapturingReplies: 9Last Post: 17th Oct 2012, 11:34 -
What Hardware/Software do I need?
By Frank W in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 7Last Post: 3rd Apr 2012, 18:30 -
Throwing Hardware At It
By doggybs in forum Media Center PC / MediaCentersReplies: 11Last Post: 21st Nov 2010, 06:47 -
Hardware Issues
By bevills1 in forum ComputerReplies: 3Last Post: 29th Oct 2009, 14:05 -
new hardware
By rallynavvie in forum ComputerReplies: 8Last Post: 20th Feb 2008, 19:43