Video noise on VOB2MPG Version 3?

[Reading Bug]

I didn’t see anything about this in other threads and my apologies if this has been corrected in an update, as I have the very first version.

Has anyone else noticed video noise when using Version 3? Version 2 created perfect-looking MPGs but with Version 3, from what I can see on my 16" laptop (haven’t burned to disc and viewed on a TV yet), I can clearly make out very subtle noise. I went back to my V2 MPGs of the same material and found nothing wrong. Viewing the V3 MPGs again, the difference was clear. I know VOB2MPG doesn’t reconvert the video, but it almost looks like it has. If there isn't definite noise, the resulting MPGs still appear to be less crisp. Anyone, or am I just seeing things?

Good to hear you’re out of the hospital Chrissyboy!

[minidv2dvd]

wow. the mpg from a vob isn't converted at all by either version. no offense but you are seeing things that just aren't there or even possible.

[lydosine]

Reading Bug - I am having the same problem.. Check the file size of the MPG vs the VOB(s) I had one where the original was 6.2GB.. The MPG turned out to be 2.4 GB. The length of the movie was correct as was the audio. But the Bit Rate was massively reduced (Stats turned on Media Player Classic showed side by side of original VOB confirmed) . I installed 2.5 then tried V3 again. This time the MPG was 4.00 GB. Still reduced quality but improved some.. I am not sure why it is essentially compressing the bit rate, this would show up as noise as you stated.

[ChrissyBoy]

Well nothing is converted - so if you can post some logs so we can see what it going on please?

[minidv2dvd]

hey how are you chrissyboy? long time to be cooped up in a germ factory.

bet you didn't know you had written an mpeg-2 encoder, did you

[Reading Bug]

Sure, here's mine. The cool emoticon pops up when "8" and ")" are back-to-back.



************************************************** ******************
************************ SYSTEM INFORMATION ************************
************************************************** ******************

***************************** VOB2MPG *****************************

Name: VOB2MPG
Title:
Version: 3.0.0020
Executable: C:\Program Files (x86)\BadgerIT\VOB2MPG v3\%APPNAME%.EXE
Executable size: 769 KB
Executable size in bytes: 787968
Executable CreationTime: 1/1/2000 12:00:00 AM
Executable LastWriteTime: 1/1/2000 12:00:00 AM
Executable LastAccessTime: 1/1/2000 12:00:00 AM
****************************** Drives *******************************

DeviceID: C:
FileSystem: NTFS
Size: 231 GB
FreeSpace: 161 GB

************************************************** ******************
********************* END OF SYSTEM INFORMATION ********************
************************************************** ******************

/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=3 /o="E:\Title_3.mpg"
11:16:57
Extracting from Title: 3

11:16:57 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
11:16:57
11:16:57 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
11:16:57
11:16:57 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
11:16:57 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
11:16:57 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
11:16:57 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
11:16:57 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
11:16:57
11:16:57 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
11:16:57
11:16:57 Extracting chapter: 1...
11:16:57 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
11:16:58 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:16:58 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
11:16:58 Extracting chapter: 2...
11:16:58 Start position: 13027328 End position: 821829632
11:29:03 Rate: 1.06MB/s (8.50Mb/s)
11:29:03 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
11:29:03 Extracting chapter: 3...
11:29:03 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
11:29:04 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:29:04 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
11:29:04 Extracting chapter: 4...
11:29:04 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
11:29:04 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:29:04 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
11:29:04 Extracting chapter: 5...
11:29:04 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
11:29:04 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:29:04 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
11:29:04 Correcting PTS values...
11:29:04 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
11:29:04
11:29:04 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
11:29:04 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
11:29:04
11:29:33 SCR Reset @ LBA 395062
11:29:33
11:29:33 SCR-1=99073124, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=99073270, PTSOFFSET=99095997, PTS-1=99076209, PTS=31263
11:29:33 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=17, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
11:29:33
11:30:23 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:01:19)
11:30:23 Finished Processing...
11:30:23 Duration (hh:mms): 00:13:26
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=4 /o="E:\Title_4.mpg"
11:50:22
Extracting from Title: 4

11:50:22 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
11:50:22
11:50:22 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
11:50:22
11:50:22 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
11:50:22 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
11:50:22 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
11:50:22 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
11:50:22 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
11:50:22
11:50:22 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
11:50:22
11:50:22 Extracting chapter: 1...
11:50:22 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
11:50:22 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:50:22 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
11:50:22 Extracting chapter: 2...
11:50:22 Start position: 821829632 End position: 1128394752
11:54:57 Rate: 1.06MB/s (8.50Mb/s)
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 3...
11:54:57 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
11:54:57 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 4...
11:54:57 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
11:54:57 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 5...
11:54:57 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
11:54:57 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
11:54:57 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
11:54:57 Correcting PTS values...
11:54:57 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
11:54:57
11:54:57 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
11:54:57 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
11:54:57
11:55:03 SCR Reset @ LBA 149829
11:55:03
11:55:03 SCR-1=34650403, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=34650549, PTSOFFSET=34672638, PTS-1=34682880, PTS=31263
11:55:03 NumFramesCoded=5, NumFramesPresented=7, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
11:55:03
11:55:39 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:00:42)
11:55:39 Finished Processing...
11:55:39 Duration (hh:mms): 00:05:17
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=6 /o="E:\Title_6.mpg"
12:20:53
Extracting from Title: 6

12:20:53 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
12:20:53
12:20:53 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
12:20:53
12:20:53 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
12:20:53 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
12:20:53 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
12:20:53 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
12:20:53 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
12:20:53
12:20:53 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
12:20:53
12:20:53 Extracting chapter: 1...
12:20:53 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
12:20:53 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
12:20:53 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
12:20:53 Extracting chapter: 2...
12:20:53 Start position: 1188265984 End position: 1647036416
12:27:51 Rate: 1.05MB/s (8.38Mb/s)
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 3...
12:27:51 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
12:27:51 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 4...
12:27:51 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
12:27:51 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 5...
12:27:51 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
12:27:51 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
12:27:51 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
12:27:51 Correcting PTS values...
12:27:51 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
12:27:51
12:27:51 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
12:27:51 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
12:27:51
12:27:59 SCR Reset @ LBA 224148
12:27:59
12:27:59 SCR-1=56299375, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=56299521, PTSOFFSET=56321265, PTS-1=56343519, PTS=31263
12:27:59 NumFramesCoded=1, NumFramesPresented=3, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
12:27:59
12:28:39 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:00:48)
12:28:39 Finished Processing...
12:28:39 Duration (hh:mms): 00:07:46
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=7 /o="E:\Title_7.mpg"
12:38:15
Extracting from Title: 7

12:38:15 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
12:38:15
12:38:15 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
12:38:15
12:38:15 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
12:38:15 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
12:38:15 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
12:38:15 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
12:38:15 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
12:38:15
12:38:15 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
12:38:15
12:38:15 Extracting chapter: 1...
12:38:15 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
12:38:17 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
12:38:17 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
12:38:17 Extracting chapter: 2...
12:38:17 Start position: 1647036416 End position: 1763381248
12:40:00 Rate: 1.07MB/s (8.60Mb/s)
12:40:00 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
12:40:00 Extracting chapter: 3...
12:40:00 Start position: 1763381248 End position: 2256764928
12:47:28 Rate: 1.05MB/s (8.37Mb/s)
12:47:28 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
12:47:28 Extracting chapter: 4...
12:47:28 Start position: 2256764928 End position: 2658119680
12:53:36 Rate: 1.04MB/s (8.31Mb/s)
12:53:36 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
12:53:36 Extracting chapter: 5...
12:53:36 Start position: 2658119680 End position: 2891313152
13:06:47 Rate: 0.28MB/s (2.24Mb/s)
13:06:47 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
13:06:47 Extracting chapter: 6...
13:06:47 Start position: 2891313152 End position: 3219668992
13:14:49 Rate: 0.65MB/s (5.19Mb/s)
13:14:49 Extracting chapter: 6... Done.
13:14:49 Extracting chapter: 7...
13:14:49 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
13:14:50 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
13:14:50 Extracting chapter: 7... Done.
13:14:50 Extracting chapter: 8...
13:14:50 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
13:14:50 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
13:14:50 Extracting chapter: 8... Done.
13:14:50 Extracting chapter: 9...
13:14:50 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
13:14:51 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
13:14:51 Extracting chapter: 9... Done.
13:14:51 Correcting PTS values...
13:14:51 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
13:14:51
13:14:51 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
13:14:51 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
13:14:51
13:17:49 SCR Reset @ LBA 768026
13:17:49
13:17:49 SCR-1=192883369, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=192883515, PTSOFFSET=192909717, PTS-1=192907947, PTS=31263
13:17:49 NumFramesCoded=9, NumFramesPresented=11, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
13:17:49
13:18:39 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:03:48)
13:18:39 Finished Processing...
13:18:39 Duration (hh:mms): 00:40:24
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=10 /o="E:\Title_10.mpg"
13:59:20
Extracting from Title: 10

13:59:20 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
13:59:20
13:59:20 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
13:59:20
13:59:20 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
13:59:20 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
13:59:20 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
13:59:20 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
13:59:20 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
13:59:20
13:59:20 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
13:59:20
13:59:20 Extracting chapter: 1...
13:59:20 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
13:59:21 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
13:59:21 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
13:59:21 Extracting chapter: 2...
13:59:21 Start position: 4100945920 End position: 4533082112
14:05:49 Rate: 1.06MB/s (8.48Mb/s)
14:05:49 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
14:05:49 Extracting chapter: 3...
14:05:49 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
14:05:49 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:05:49 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
14:05:49 Extracting chapter: 4...
14:05:49 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
14:05:49 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:05:49 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
14:05:49 Extracting chapter: 5...
14:05:49 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
14:05:50 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:05:50 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
14:05:50 Correcting PTS values...
14:05:50 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
14:05:50
14:05:50 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
14:05:50 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
14:05:50
14:05:58 SCR Reset @ LBA 211143
14:05:58
14:05:58 SCR-1=48866097, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=48866243, PTSOFFSET=48891843, PTS-1=48902085, PTS=31263
14:05:58 NumFramesCoded=5, NumFramesPresented=7, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
14:05:58
14:06:58 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:01:08)
14:06:58 Finished Processing...
14:06:58 Duration (hh:mms): 00:07:38
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=8 /o="E:\Title_8.mpg"
14:44:43
Extracting from Title: 8

14:44:43 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
14:44:43
14:44:43 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
14:44:43
14:44:43 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
14:44:43 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
14:44:43 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
14:44:43 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
14:44:43 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
14:44:43
14:44:43 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
14:44:43
14:44:43 Extracting chapter: 1...
14:44:43 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
14:44:44 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:44:44 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
14:44:44 Extracting chapter: 2...
14:44:44 Start position: 3219668992 End position: 3827253248
14:53:54 Rate: 1.05MB/s (8.41Mb/s)
14:53:54 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
14:53:54 Extracting chapter: 3...
14:53:54 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
14:53:54 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:53:54 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
14:53:54 Extracting chapter: 4...
14:53:54 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
14:53:55 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:53:55 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
14:53:55 Extracting chapter: 5...
14:53:55 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
14:53:55 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
14:53:55 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
14:53:55 Correcting PTS values...
14:53:55 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
14:53:55
14:53:55 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
14:53:55 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
14:53:55
14:54:07 SCR Reset @ LBA 296811
14:54:07
14:54:07 SCR-1=74590254, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=74590400, PTSOFFSET=74615541, PTS-1=74595753, PTS=31263
14:54:07 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=17, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
14:54:07
14:54:57 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:01:01)
14:54:57 Finished Processing...
14:54:57 Duration (hh:mms): 00:10:14
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=9 /o="E:\Title_9.mpg"
15:19:42
Extracting from Title: 9

15:19:42 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
15:19:42
15:19:42 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
15:19:42
15:19:42 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
15:19:42 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
15:19:42 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
15:19:42 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
15:19:42 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
15:19:42
15:19:42 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
15:19:42
15:19:42 Extracting chapter: 1...
15:19:42 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
15:19:42 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:19:42 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
15:19:42 Extracting chapter: 2...
15:19:42 Start position: 3827253248 End position: 4100945920
15:23:45 Rate: 1.07MB/s (8.60Mb/s)
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 3...
15:23:45 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
15:23:45 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 4...
15:23:45 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
15:23:45 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 5...
15:23:45 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
15:23:45 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:23:45 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
15:23:45 Correcting PTS values...
15:23:45 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
15:23:45
15:23:45 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
15:23:45 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
15:23:45
15:23:51 SCR Reset @ LBA 133778
15:23:51
15:23:51 SCR-1=30958245, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=30958391, PTSOFFSET=30984954, PTS-1=30986187, PTS=31263
15:23:51 NumFramesCoded=8, NumFramesPresented=10, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
15:23:51
15:24:15 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:00:29)
15:24:15 Finished Processing...
15:24:15 Duration (hh:mms): 00:04:33
/v="D:\VIDEO_TS" /t=5 /o="E:\Title_5.mpg"
15:32:01
Extracting from Title: 5

15:32:01 vPaths: D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB,D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB, D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB,
15:32:01
15:32:01 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
15:32:01
15:32:01 VTS_01_1.VOB : Length = 1073324032 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 1073324032 (0.99 GB)
15:32:01 VTS_01_2.VOB : Length = 1073424384 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 2146748416 (1.99 GB)
15:32:01 VTS_01_3.VOB : Length = 1073604608 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 3220353024 (2.99 GB)
15:32:01 VTS_01_4.VOB : Length = 1073534976 (0.99 GB) : vPosition = 4293888000 (3.99 GB)
15:32:01 VTS_01_5.VOB : Length = 239194112 (228 MB) : vPosition = 4533082112 (4.22 GB)
15:32:01
15:32:01 =============== Virtual File Details ===============
15:32:01
15:32:01 Extracting chapter: 1...
15:32:01 Start position: 12744704 End position: 13027328
15:32:02 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:32:02 Extracting chapter: 1... Done.
15:32:02 Extracting chapter: 2...
15:32:02 Start position: 1128394752 End position: 1188265984
15:32:50 Rate: 1.18MB/s (9.45Mb/s)
15:32:50 Extracting chapter: 2... Done.
15:32:50 Extracting chapter: 3...
15:32:50 Start position: 12462080 End position: 12556288
15:32:50 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:32:50 Extracting chapter: 3... Done.
15:32:50 Extracting chapter: 4...
15:32:50 Start position: 12556288 End position: 12650496
15:32:51 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:32:51 Extracting chapter: 4... Done.
15:32:51 Extracting chapter: 5...
15:32:51 Start position: 12650496 End position: 12744704
15:32:51 Rate: 0.00MB/s (0.00Mb/s)
15:32:51 Extracting chapter: 5... Done.
15:32:51 Correcting PTS values...
15:32:51 SCR Reset @ LBA 139
15:32:51
15:32:51 SCR-1=96672, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=96818, PTSOFFSET=135135, PTS-1=121353, PTS=25257
15:32:51 NumFramesCoded=15, NumFramesPresented=13, tsn=2, tsnGOP=0
15:32:51
15:32:53 SCR Reset @ LBA 29373
15:32:53
15:32:53 SCR-1=6128872, SCR=0, SCROFFSET=6129018, PTSOFFSET=6174168, PTS-1=6196422, PTS=31263
15:32:53 NumFramesCoded=1, NumFramesPresented=3, tsn=0, tsnGOP=2
15:32:53
15:33:02 Correcting PTS values... DONE (00:00:10)
15:33:02 Finished Processing...
15:33:02 Duration (hh:mms): 00:01:00

[ChrissyBoy]

Ok. How about doing this, to put this to bed....

Use DGIndex on a mpg from v2.5 and v3 (from the same DVD):



Choose a frame and post the still bmp (F7 in DGIndex) of each so we can see the "noise". Also you can use the tool to show the [b]actual[b/] bitrate (not the nominal one you get in MPC). Again post screenshots at the same frame so we can see the "massively reduced" bitrate.