What i mean i i know they don't record the movie again e.g. the godfather was on dvd and now it on blu-ray how did they do that?
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 13 of 13
-
-
In the case of The Godfather, that is exactly what they did. The rescanned it and completely restored it, then they produced DVDs and Blurays from the same high Definition master (much higher than Bluray allows for).Originally Posted by newmovementz
No studio of any note will take a DVD version, upscale it, and release it as Bluray. When mastering for Bluray, the film is scanned at higher than Bluray resolution, processed in whatever way is deemed necessary depending on the budget for the release, the quality of the source, and the perceived value to the studio, and then encoded multiple times for dofferent uses. They will encode it to DVD spec for DVD, Bluray spec for Bluray, and may even encode a lower spec version for digital download.
While many studios made HD scans when preping work for DVD release, knowing that something better was coming, many are finding that they need to scan the prints again to reach the level of quality that is expected in a modern release.
Bottom line though, they do not start with a low quality source and build up. The start with a high quality source, and go down from there.Read my blog here.
-
What's kind of a drag though is some of the clean-up they are doing. Many of the older films are losing their original flavor (and some detail at times) as film grain has been deemed unacceptable for the new breed of movie watchers. A similar phenomena is apparent with 120Hz LCD's. Older great films just look different.
-
A good restoration should be just that - restoring the film to it's former glory. The Godfather is a good example of a digital restoration done right, as is Casablanca. One of the most astounding I have seen is Rear Window, not only because the end result is so incredible, but also because it was a chemical restoration, not a digital one.
Read my blog here.
-
I can't stand grain in a film,I wish all transfers were done to THX standards by Lucasfilm et al.I don't like what Turner did to the old B&W classics,colorizing looks awful*.
Transferring a film is laborious and most films look great on Blu-ray while some early releases don't look any better than DVD.
*I do give Turner credit for saving the old films and restoring them for future generations. -
A rather odd post, you "can't stand grain in a film" yet you didn't like what Turner did to old classics? As far as George Lucas, I wish he had stopped making movies after Howard The Duck, it was all down hill after that.Originally Posted by MOVIEGEEK
-
Love grain in film - I purposely add some every encode despite the added bitrate requirements. It gives it that classic cinematic effect.
But hey, to each their own right?I hate VHS. I always did. -
MysticE,
George Lucas owns THX,ILM and of course Lucasfilm.You may not care for his films but THX and ILM have advanced the art of filmmaking.
Turner colorized the old MGM catalog which I don't like but at least he cleaned them up,there's a difference between color and grain. -
Exactly!!!!Originally Posted by MOVIEGEEK
Cleaning and restoring is one thing, colorizing old B&W movies is probably one of the most worthless things to have ever been done!!! -
Maybe moviemaking would be a more appropriate term.Originally Posted by MOVIEGEEK
-
AFTER???Originally Posted by MysticE

To each his own, as I think it is VERY worthwhile, as long as it's done tastefully and with the full cooperation of the rightsholders/creators and with high quality and preservation foremost in mind. Unfortunately, there are a number of examples where the process was undertaken without fulfilling those requirements...Originally Posted by Noahtuck
Scott -
Well, all the one's i have sampled never looked right & the original B&W version is preferred over some crayola coloring hack jobOriginally Posted by Cornucopia
But really, they never ever look right 8)
Similar Threads
-
Out of sync audio when ripping blu-ray film
By Odaik in forum Video ConversionReplies: 3Last Post: 12th Jul 2011, 13:14 -
Want to copy Blu-Ray film only no menus, previews, ads, etc.
By jcikal in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 2Last Post: 15th Sep 2010, 16:49 -
Need help fitting a compressed Blu ray film 1080p into a DL DVD
By jones24 in forum Authoring (Blu-ray)Replies: 9Last Post: 26th Sep 2009, 22:21 -
Want to make hi-def DVD to play in blu-ray player
By amfriedman in forum Authoring (Blu-ray)Replies: 3Last Post: 24th Mar 2009, 22:12 -
Can I rip Blu Ray Discs with LG Super Multi Blu-ray Disc and HD DVD-ROM Dri
By donpato in forum Blu-ray RippingReplies: 5Last Post: 5th May 2008, 17:05



Quote