VideoHelp Forum




+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 4 of 4
  1. Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Search Comp PM
    Of course this thread is an excellent in-depth guide to aspect ratios...

    https://forum.videohelp.com/topic174200.html

    ...but since I am still a little green in this area and this is a bit overwhelming, could someone well versed in achieving different aspect ratios in NLEs advise me on the following?

    > I am editing a film shot in 16:9 SD MiniDV, on a 16:9 timeline (in Avid Liquid). I am experimenting and want to apply black bars above and below my picture, to give the impression of an aspect ratio wider than 16:9. I am achieving this with a combination of cropping above and below, and also squeezing the picture slightly vertically (which I know will distort the picture and make everything look a bit 'wider', but I want this as a stylistic effect anyway).

    My question is, to achieve the following correct aspect ratios, how many horizontal pixel lines from above and below the picture should I remove?

    [1] 1.85:1 = ( 37:20 )
    [2] 2.20:1 = ( 11:5 )
    [3] 2.35:1 = ( 47:20 )

    To experiment I am currently guessing it at around 1.85:1 and am pleased with the visual effect, but before I start cropping the whole film this way I thought I may as well find out what the correct pixel-removal amounts are.

    Can someone supply the calculations, or explain in simple terms how to figure it out?

    Thank you for any help
    Quote Quote  
  2. Always Watching guns1inger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Miskatonic U
    Search Comp PM
    For

    2.35 : 1 - crop to 720 x 336 (4:3), then resize 336 to 448 for 16:9. Assumes 4:3 source. If you have 16:9 source, just crop to 448 then pad to 576

    2.20 : 1 - crop to 720 x 352 (4:3), then resize to 480 for 16:9. If you have 16:9 source, just crop to 480 then pad to 576

    1.85 : 1 - crop to 720 x 432 (4:3) then resize up to 560 for 16:9. If you have 16:9 source then just crop to 560 and pad to 576.

    All of these numbers assume PAL
    Read my blog here.
    Quote Quote  
  3. Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    United Kingdom
    Search Comp PM
    Thank you Gunslinger - but im still uncertain so just to clarify:-

    720 is my screen width - this will not change, only height. By the way my 16:9 timeline properties are 720 x 576 [non-square].

    So to achieve a picture size of 1.85:1, I shrink the height of the picture from 576 down to 432 pixels [and so-on for the other aspect ratio sizes I listed] based on the information in your reply?

    Like I say I will achieve the black bars with a 2D Editor using a combination of 'height reduction' and 'cropping', and the final picture size is all I am concerned with, not the correction of the image [which will look like a slightly widened 16:9 picture].

    So I just need to do the maths to work out how much to squeeze/crop in the 2D Editor to bring me down to 432 pixels high [1.85:1], 352 pixels high [2.20:1] or 336 pixels high [2.35:1]?

    Thanks for any further clarification
    Quote Quote  
  4. You want to crop the height of the frame then restore it by adding black bars:

    For a 720x576 16:9 source the remaining picture height should be:

    height = 576 * 1.77777 / (desired AR)

    So, to make it 2.35:1 you need a picture height of ~436 (576 * 1.77777 / 2.35). Crop a total of 140 (576-436) lines off the top and/or bottom (it doesn't necessarily have to be half and half). Then restore the frame by adding a total of 140 lines of black to the top and bottom (again, it doesn't necessarily have to be equal amounts).
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads

Visit our sponsor! Try DVDFab and backup Blu-rays!