Jumpy video when played on DVD- Complient Mpeg2 Upperfield

[daniel9801]

Pity it has to come to this but yeah thanks alot, much appreciated

[Panash]

TMPGENC can do compliant MPEG streams, no problem... if done correctly.

Since when? There is a subtle fault in TMPGenc in the temporal structure which some players are sensitive to - see my posting at

https://www.videohelp.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=215429&highlight=

This is a fault that would be easily corrected if Hori San was aware of the problem but there isn't a means of making him aware of this fault.

I get really p*ssed off when the 'experts' try to shout the 'noobs' down on this because in doing so it masks easily correctable faults and perpetuates myths that TMPGenc is perfect, or it is the best. Quite simply it is flawed and every so often this fault catches people out with problems like this and time and time again the 'experts' trot out the standard answers like 'have you tried this profile or that profile', and so fundemental problem within the software never get addressed.


Now Lordsmurf you need to take on board that there is a problem with TMPGenc and try and use your influence to try and get it corrected. I've given up on TMPGenc and moved onto othe encoders that do give flawless, complient MPEG. I can see that less experienced 'noobs' could easily get disillussioned with mpeg encoding and give up.

PN