Another head to head shoot out :)

[stiltman]

This thread was inspired by the thread "How do these look"

It's a striaght up (as far as I can tell) comparison between;
- DVD2One v1.40 "Constant Ratio" (as recommended for long movies).
- IC8 "High Quality" / "Anamorphic (16:9)".
- DVD Shrink v3.2b3.

Go to this link here
Download and judge. I don't know the answers only "ddlooping" does.
You can also post your findings here

From original thread
Sorry not registered there, so i'll post here

I looked at compilation 1 only (for right now)
VTS_01_1.VOB = the original of course
VTS_02_1.VOB = pretty good, noticed pixelation around fire. Not bad though
VTS_03_1.VOB = same as the one above
VTS_04_1.VOB = worst of them all by far. I hope it's not IC8

IMO,
VTS_01_1.VOB = original
VTS_02_1.VOB = InstantCopy 8
VTS_03_1.VOB = DVDShrink
VTS_04_1.VOB = DVD2ONE

[disturbed1]

I looked at compilation 1 only (for right now)
VTS_01_1.VOB = the original of course
VTS_02_1.VOB = pretty good, noticed pixelation around fire. Not bad though
VTS_03_1.VOB = same as the one above
VTS_04_1.VOB = worst of them all by far. I hope it's not IC8

I agree with the above while looking at compilation #2.

1 was original
2 wasn't bad
3 didn't cut it
4 didn't cut it either but was much worse than 3

[MOVIEGEEK]

DVDShrink 3.2b3?
I thought 3.1.7 was the latest.
ddlooping,what have you and Dr.Shrink been doing these past months?

BTW...my money is on DVDShrink having the best quality.

[soundforbjt]

Since DVD Shrink 3.2 is coming out soon. My picks are;

First compilation

1. original
2. DVDShrink
3. Instant Copy 8
4. DVD2One

[ddlooping]

Hi all.

To those of you who took a shot at it, I'll pm the answers for "Compilation 1".
Please keep them confidential so as not to spoil the game for others.

[noki]

Along the same line...
I have seen the result of DVD2One on the WS version of TROK...really soft and lost of color contrast. Personally DVDFab on 2 dvdrs looked great, just like the original .

[ddlooping]

disturbed1, would you care to give your answers?

[disturbed1]

1. Original
2. DVDShrink
3. IC8
4. DVD2One

But that's from #2, unless they are in a different order for #1.