VideoHelp Forum




+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 10
  1. Ok.... after all the hype of this program i thought i must check it out. It sounded too good to be true. And it was

    I tested a DVD which was 7.8 gigs. First thing i didnt like about this program was the fact if you want to remove bits from there, e.g. Special features etc.. dont expect it to work in your standalone player. unlike shrink and IC8 you cant compress certain title sets to what u like, it is all automatically done for you. You only have the option of removing them.

    I done a full disc backup of the dvd using IC8, Shrink (latest version) and Intervideo DVD copy 2 (platinum version). Speed wise Intervideo comes out top, but id rather have a watchable copy than a crap rushed one.

    Below are the results:
    1. IC8 - Definatley on top Quality was just superb
    2. Shrink - Not too far behind from IC8 with deep analysis
    3. DVD Copy 2 By far the Worst.

    I found the Intervideo software left huge artifacts during the film. it couldnt even display the production company logo properly. The warning screen had huge artifacts. I also noticed artifacts running throughout the entire movie. It has really put me off the software.

    Im going to try and run another test this weekend using another movie. maybe "Matrix Reloaded", and give it a chance to redeem itself.

    My two cents worth stick to Instant Copy or Shrink.
    Quote Quote  
  2. You must have done something wrong. It came out on top for me ahead of Recode 2. It did have some small artifacts, but was overall sharper image then Recode 2 @60% level.
    Quote Quote  
  3. Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    HELLsinki, Finland
    Search Comp PM
    Intervideo DVD copy is also in my opinion a huge disappointment. Have compared results of Traffic (~7.5gb) with it, Shrink and CCE. Obviously CCE was top-notch, but Shrink came second (nothing to cheer about though). Intervideo was disastrous Huge macroblocks and vertical lines...

    But if it works for you, congratulations...it didnīt for me...

    "This is true in all walks of life: Man takes care of the quantity, woman the quality."
    Quote Quote  
  4. Intervideo DVD copy 2 Platinum...worst of all the transcoders IMHO.
    Last Saturday evening...wanted to backup a 7.41G DVD in which the main movie was 6.91G. first up was IV 2...VIDEO_TS output folder content was only 3.97G. It was not even playable in PowerDVD (though i was able to double-click on one of the produced vob's within the folder and it played in PowerDVD [quality was actually good]. too bad the movie could not play from the beginning). i think i used it correctly. just selected DVD, main movie, and one audio track. pretty much fool-proof. it was fast, though
    Next up was DVD2One. Faster than IV2 and excellent video; very, very close to original.
    Last up was DVD Shrink 3.0b5. Slow w_DA but excellent results. If i had to choose I would say Shrink's copy was the best by only a hair over DVD2One.
    Quote Quote  
  5. Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    Thank God I did not pay the 9.95 to upgrade to it . I got it for free :P Clonedvd2 is way better.
    Quote Quote  
  6. Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    ontario ,canada
    Search Comp PM
    There tech support has admitted there are problems with aspects of the new version.Anything but whole disk backup will cause errors.One tech e-mailed me and admitted it didn't work for him either.
    Well have to wait until platinum 2 is fixed.
    bmiller,ont.canada
    Quote Quote  
  7. Banned
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    United States
    Search Comp PM
    dont know why everyone has so much trouble with it.

    it gives me nothing but superb results
    Quote Quote  
  8. Member jbelder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Denver,Co
    Search Comp PM
    Originally Posted by busipaln
    Ok.... after all the hype of this program i thought i must check it out. It sounded too good to be true. And it was

    I tested a DVD which was 7.8 gigs. First thing i didnt like about this program was the fact if you want to remove bits from there, e.g. Special features etc.. dont expect it to work in your standalone player. unlike shrink and IC8 you cant compress certain title sets to what u like, it is all automatically done for you. You only have the option of removing them.

    I done a full disc backup of the dvd using IC8, Shrink (latest version) and Intervideo DVD copy 2 (platinum version). Speed wise Intervideo comes out top, but id rather have a watchable copy than a crap rushed one.

    Below are the results:
    1. IC8 - Definatley on top Quality was just superb
    2. Shrink - Not too far behind from IC8 with deep analysis
    3. DVD Copy 2 By far the Worst.

    I found the Intervideo software left huge artifacts during the film. it couldnt even display the production company logo properly. The warning screen had huge artifacts. I also noticed artifacts running throughout the entire movie. It has really put me off the software.

    Im going to try and run another test this weekend using another movie. maybe "Matrix Reloaded", and give it a chance to redeem itself.

    My two cents worth stick to Instant Copy or Shrink.
    I use V1.2 and haven't any artifacting or pixelation. I have done 500+ movies with no problems at all quality is 100%. Just started using 2.0 looks good to me
    James B Elder
    Quote Quote  
  9. Member jbelder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Denver,Co
    Search Comp PM
    Originally Posted by busipaln
    Ok.... after all the hype of this program i thought i must check it out. It sounded too good to be true. And it was

    I tested a DVD which was 7.8 gigs. First thing i didnt like about this program was the fact if you want to remove bits from there, e.g. Special features etc.. dont expect it to work in your standalone player. unlike shrink and IC8 you cant compress certain title sets to what u like, it is all automatically done for you. You only have the option of removing them.

    I done a full disc backup of the dvd using IC8, Shrink (latest version) and Intervideo DVD copy 2 (platinum version). Speed wise Intervideo comes out top, but id rather have a watchable copy than a crap rushed one.

    Below are the results:
    1. IC8 - Definatley on top Quality was just superb
    2. Shrink - Not too far behind from IC8 with deep analysis
    3. DVD Copy 2 By far the Worst.

    I found the Intervideo software left huge artifacts during the film. it couldnt even display the production company logo properly. The warning screen had huge artifacts. I also noticed artifacts running throughout the entire movie. It has really put me off the software.

    Im going to try and run another test this weekend using another movie. maybe "Matrix Reloaded", and give it a chance to redeem itself.

    My two cents worth stick to Instant Copy or Shrink.
    I use Intervideo 1.2 and 2.0 , backed up all three lord of the rings and I don't see any problems what so ever,actually on any dvds I've backed up 500+. What kind of media are you using?
    James B Elder
    Quote Quote  
  10. Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Finland...
    Search Comp PM
    From what I've seen Intervideos transcoder works better with PAL DVDs... dont know why though...
    Quote Quote  



Similar Threads

Visit our sponsor! Try DVDFab and backup Blu-rays!