@lordsmurf, you do realise I was talking about general use and nothing about quality . The rough guesstimate of 50 was just to show that it's obviously used far more than DVD2One

I haven't used DVD2One for ages so does DVD2One now have preview, title removal or allow variable compression on different titles?

on a movie-only DVD2One may in people's opinions give the better quality on certain occasions. If it's a uniform reduction overall doing a 1:1 then DVDShrink may just give the better quality in the main movie due to it allowing lower quality in the menu/extras

@niltram, I agree being free will make a huge difference in use. Any software that is free doesn't mean it's the best, it's just one of the factors. These various factors are why there is such as variation in opinion as people have various requirements and opinions of output, never mind the other factors

@pippocalo, IC7 was exactly the same regarding stripping the crap and Pinnacle knew this before releasing IC8 . That doesn't mean you cannot remove extras as there are quite a few methods and programs that can do it now