DVDShrink vs CloneDVD vs DVDStriper

[Shtirlits]

Hi,

Since I'm new and havingn a hard time to decide which tool to go with I would like to hear your opinion on this. Presently which tool does the most officiant job if you only want to back up a movie without any extras except having the menus?

Thank you very much for your help.

[ddlooping]

Hi Shtirlits.

DVD Shrink doesn't allow for "menu(s)-movie-only" backups.
CloneDVD, Nero Recode do.
DVDStripper does not "compress", so if after deleting all the "extras" the files total size is still too big to fit on a DVD-R, you will have to use one of the softwares mentionned above (or DVD2One, DVD95Copy, ...).
So of the three you named in the subject of this thread, only CloneDVD or DVDStripper (if no compression is needed) fit your requirements.