Verbatim DVDs with very high PI error/failure rates at the end of discs

inoueto · Member Joined: 10 Mar 2005 Location: Canada

I have Pioneer DVR-115 drive & burned most of DVDs on Verbatim 16x medias. While it does not show any noticeable incompatibility issues with any devices (DVD player, PC burner, etc.), I have noticed that it always give very questionable scan results on “Nero CD-DVD speed.” While they always find no errors on “Benchmark” (speed tests) & “ScanDisc” tests, they always give very high PI error (above 16,000) & PI failure (above 600) rates at the end of discs; hence, they always give “0” quality scores (just like the image I attached in below: they also give exact same results with Verbatim DVD+R medias with MCC004 codes). I tried to burn with different speeds (16x, 8x, 4x, etc) and different software (Nero, ImgBurn, etc.), but no matter with whatever combination, it always give same results.

I recently tried Taiyo Yuden 8x DVD-Rs (Value line), and scans on these give far much better results (quality scores of 97-98, with very low PI error rates), however some of my DVD player doesn’t like some of the TY discs (stuttered play back, or jerky forward/backward motions).

I was just wandering if I really need to take these PI error/failure rates seriously & need to switch to TY, or if it doesn’t mean anything serious & I could stick to Verbatim for a while (--other than these scary scan results, Verbatim discs would give no problems in actual uses). With frequent sales around, Verbatim discs are much cheaper & easier to find in my area. For example, there is a sale of 25 pack Verbatim Digital Movie 8x for 4.99, and I just wandered if I should get these or not…

http://www.futureshop.ca/marketing/sale_this_week/proddetailpc.as ... langid=EN#

I would appreciate it very much for any thoughts on this matter. Thanks.

lordsmurf · Posted: Mar 03, 2009 18:08

You can't scan with that drive.
_________________
digitalFAQ.com -- Help with VHS to DVD, DVD recorders, other video/photo issues.
NoMoreCoasters.com -- How to avoid bad burns, how to find the best blank DVDs.

inoueto · Member Joined: 10 Mar 2005 Location: Canada

Dear Lordsmurf;

Thank you very much for your reply. So, what you are saying is, Pioneer drives cannot perform PI error/failure scans accurately, and I shouldn't consider these PI error/failure rates seriously (--unless discs gives errors on "Speed" test or "ScanDisc" test), is that correct?

P.S. I just found out that, as Lordsmurf said, most recent version of Nero Disc Speed cannot perform PI error/failure scans on my pioneer drive (but only older versions will do the scans).

inoueto · Member Joined: 10 Mar 2005 Location: Canada

For just in case, I just bought Verbatim digital movie 8x which were on sale, and scanned the first burned DVD. It looks far much better than the ones I bought bunch two years ago (Verbatim 25 pack 16x from the year 2004-5 with the old package--seems like out sourced to Prodisc in which the inner Hub-code starting MAP...).

I know the scan on Pioneer drives won't be reliable, but it might indicate something...? I don't know...

budz · Posted: Mar 05, 2009 00:56

As LS told you PIONEER drives are not used for scanning with CD/DVD SPEED. NONE of the OLDER PIONEER drives can be used for scanning as well. You'd have to use LITEON, SAMSUNG & BENQ for quality scans. Go to CDFREAKS.COM and you can visit the forums there. They have PIONEER, SAMSUNG, LG, BENQ, LITEON & NEC forums for dvd burners. LITEON, SAMSUNG & BENQ are the only drives you can use to get quality scans. Your scans you posted don't mean anything. Do some reading/research at CDFREAKS.com. Seriously though the only time you'd do a quality scan is if the discs you're burning are having problems playing back in your standalone dvd players.

lordsmurf · Posted: Mar 05, 2009 08:43

Scans in general don't necessarily mean anything, but Pioneer probably is the least accurate of all. It's easily one of the best readers and burners, but it's not a scanner. I think you're overly worrying. Use good media, in a good drive, and make sure the data is created well (authored compliant, etc). Do surface scans and speed readers, forget the PI/PO stuff. If those are good, you're fine.
_________________
digitalFAQ.com -- Help with VHS to DVD, DVD recorders, other video/photo issues.
NoMoreCoasters.com -- How to avoid bad burns, how to find the best blank DVDs.

inoueto · Member Joined: 10 Mar 2005 Location: Canada

Dear budz & Lordsmurf;

Thank you for your comments. Indeed, any Verbatim discs I burned had no serious troubles reading in any devices, so I shouldn’t worry too much. I tried TY, but for some reasons, I thought I still prefer using Verbatim for several reasons: #1 cost & availability; #2 I don’t like the silver thermal top of TY, which attracts dust & finger prints; #3 some player don’t like TY for some reason, etc.

Indeed, surface scan test shows no problems what-so-ever for all Verbatim medias. The Speed test showed slight preference for “digital movie 8x” over 16x older package (which showed series of small dips toward the end, while “digital movie” shows more straight curves all the way through). I might grab bunch of digital movie ones while the sale lasts

.

lordsmurf · Posted: Mar 05, 2009 12:18

You've nailed TY problems down precisely. Those are all valid complaints.
_________________
digitalFAQ.com -- Help with VHS to DVD, DVD recorders, other video/photo issues.
NoMoreCoasters.com -- How to avoid bad burns, how to find the best blank DVDs.

MysticE · Dismembered Joined: 17 Nov 2003 Location: United States

LCSHG · Member Joined: 25 Jan 2005

Inoueto

lordsmurf said
‘I think you're overly worrying Use good media, in a good drive, and make sure the data is created well"

An old saying
“If it ain’t broke don’t Fix It’

As to NERO I don’t think much of it or its tests.. I did use its full erase [it was free and did ok] in an older version some 3 years ago.

MysticE · Dismembered Joined: 17 Nov 2003 Location: United States