INDEX  F.A.Q.  SEARCH  LATEST POSTS     Rules  Register  Profile  Private messages  Login


Search all forums or this forum: Advanced search
SPDIF - Why can't lossless multichannel audio be transmitted?
Forum Index -> Video -> Audio Printer-friendly version
Reply to topic
Author Message
ontherocks
Member


Joined: 19 Aug 2007
Location: United States
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 08:51 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
AFAIK the reason stated as to why lossless multichannel audio cannot be sent through SPDIF is due its upper limit on bandwitdh (which is essentially bitrate)
SPDIF specifies 2 channel PCM, up to 20 bits per sample, at any sample rate.
But then "at any sample rate" means that there is no upper limit on bitrate. Why is then that lossless multichannel audio cannot be transmitted?

Last edited by ontherocks on Jul 04, 2008 13:57, edited 1 time in total
Midzuki
RETIRED


Joined: 25 Jun 2007
Location: Outside of VH.com
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 09:29 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
ontherocks
Member


Joined: 19 Aug 2007
Location: United States
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 10:55 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
Yes, seen that and lots of other references before.
Unfortunately none of them answer my question.

Midzuki
RETIRED


Joined: 25 Jun 2007
Location: Outside of VH.com
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 11:32 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
Quote:
SPDIF specifies 2 channel PCM, up to 20 bits per sample, at any sample rate.
But then "at any sample rate" means that there is no upper limit on bitrate.


That's the "theory", so to speak. However the devices and the medium that the SPDIFed
signals travel through do impose practical limits to the achievable data transfer rate.
For a change, such "practical limits" are defined more by the industrial standards and
less by the laws of Physics. sad.gif

aedipuss
aBigMeanie


Joined: 25 Oct 2005
Location: 666th portal
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 12:26 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
just how high a bitrate are you talking about? i have no problems with DD 448kbps, DTS 640kbps or pcm @1536kbps over spdif. what's your source audio bitrate?
_________________
--
"a lot of people are better dead" - prisoner KSC2-303

ontherocks
Member


Joined: 19 Aug 2007
Location: United States
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 13:14 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
@Midzuki
Any idea what is the industrial limit?

@aedipuss
Try any lossless multichannel audio (compressed or uncompressed) and see if you can transmit it as it is through SPDIF (multichannel flac, MLP, Dolby TrueHD, dts-HDMA, etc)

Last edited by ontherocks on Jul 04, 2008 13:57, edited 2 times in total
aedipuss
aBigMeanie


Joined: 25 Oct 2005
Location: 666th portal
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 13:23 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
i'd probably need a different receiver/amplifier on the other end of my spdif optical cable. it only does pcm, dolby prologic, dolby digital, and dts. i have a feeling it would only output hiss with anything else. but if you have a sample you can upload somewhere, i'd download it and try. i don't have any to test it with.
_________________
--
"a lot of people are better dead" - prisoner KSC2-303

ontherocks
Member


Joined: 19 Aug 2007
Location: United States
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 13:51 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
@aedipuss
You can get samples here http://2l.no/hires/index.html
You don't need a different receiver. What you have is perfectly fine. Use foobar.

levick
Member


Joined: 04 Aug 2005
Location: AKL, NZ
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 14:07 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
the standard toslink and coax digital connection does not have the bandwidth capacity to carry the new HD audio formats...and it appears that most blue ray or HD DVD machines are designed to transmit the HD audio signals down the HDMI lead..the Samsung I use scales back the audio to SD version for transmission down the toshlink or coax leads.

aedipuss
aBigMeanie


Joined: 25 Oct 2005
Location: 666th portal
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 15:05 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
i tried the 2L50SACD_tr01_multi_48.flac and the corresponding 5.1 dts wav files. foobar will play the first but not the dts. powerdvd will play the dts. they both appear to be sent over the spdif as 2 ch. pcm. all that is output is stereo, and the dts file doesn't light the dts display on the receiver.
_________________
--
"a lot of people are better dead" - prisoner KSC2-303

ontherocks
Member


Joined: 19 Aug 2007
Location: United States
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 15:42 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
Yep, thats precisely the thing I am talking about.
Lossless multichannel is sent over as 2 channel over SPDIF. The reason people state is what I mentioned in my first post (not enough bandwidth)

(BTW what was the problem with dts.wav file in foobar? Did you get static noise or some error? FYI dolby digital a.k.a ac3 and dts are lossy multichannel and hence transmits fine over SPDIF)

aedipuss
aBigMeanie


Joined: 25 Oct 2005
Location: 666th portal
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 16:14 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
foobar just output the 5.1 dts wav as hiss, no error.
_________________
--
"a lot of people are better dead" - prisoner KSC2-303

edDV
Member


Joined: 06 Mar 2004
Location: Northern California, USA
Post Posted: Jul 04, 2008 16:41 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
If S/PDIF doesn't get where you want, implememt Pro AES equipment for uncompressed multichannel (4 at a time) over coax or XLR twisted pair. S/PDIF is the reduced cost consumer version of AES. The cost reduction comes from the connectors and chips used. S/PDIF is intended for AC3, DTS and PCM stereo.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S/PDIF
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AES
http://www.tech-faq.com/aes-ebu.shtml
_________________
Recommends: Kiva.org - Loans that change lives.
http://www.kiva.org/about

ontherocks
Member


Joined: 19 Aug 2007
Location: United States
Post Posted: Jul 06, 2008 10:52 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
aedipuss wrote:
foobar just output the 5.1 dts wav as hiss, no error.


You have to turn up the volume to the maximum everywhere in Windows Audio Controller (double click on speaker icon on taskbar) and Foobar. Control the volume through your A/V Receiver only.
Look here http://staraphd.blogspot.com/2007/10/get-51-or-71-multichannel-audio-from.html

aedipuss
aBigMeanie


Joined: 25 Oct 2005
Location: 666th portal
Post Posted: Jul 06, 2008 12:45 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
interesting. installing the foobar spdif passthrough .dll allows the 5.1 dts file to play, after renaming it from .wav to .dts. full 6 channel dts, and it lights the receiver dts display led.

but now foobar can't output the 5.1 ch. flac at all. no audio period. may be because it's 48khz and the dts is 41khz? i'm downloading a 96khz 5.1ch flac file to try.
_________________
--
"a lot of people are better dead" - prisoner KSC2-303

aedipuss
aBigMeanie


Joined: 25 Oct 2005
Location: 666th portal
Post Posted: Jul 06, 2008 17:04 Posts Comp View users profile Send private message Reply with quote
turns out the 5.1 flac was still playable but after playing the dts the receiver won't play anything else but dts until it's reset. downloaded the 96khz flac, 96khz wav, and 48khz 5.1 wav to test also. they all play, but it seems they all get converted to 2ch. pcm before being sent to the receiver.

something's not quite right as my sound card is set to output 96khz 24bit out the spdif, but it doesn't appear to do it. the flac should be just hiss, as the receiver wouldn't know what to do with it anyway, as it only decodes pcm, dolby, dolby digital, and dts, but the high bitrate wavs should work.
_________________
--
"a lot of people are better dead" - prisoner KSC2-303

Reply to topic All times are GMT - 6 Hours
Forum Index -> Video -> Audio Page 1 of 1





You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Jump to:  
Display:   
About   Advertise   Forum Archive   RSS Feeds   Statistics