I am being strongly advised to turn off Noise Reduction on my VCR and re-do the captures.
However I cannot find any option to do this ?
The VCR 'was' an expensive pro-sumer 4 head model, Panasonic NV-HS800 .... referred to as SVHS PAL Superdrive
It does have the AI Crystal View ... but have this 'off'
(this is described as dedicated microprocessor control of tapehead to circuitry)
There is a soft-sharp slider ... always been left at centre position.
16:9 left at auto
Anybody know if there is NR disable feature?
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 25 of 25
My little Panasonic NV-HD620 has Crystal View so I would not read much into that.
Had never turned it 'on' ... just mentioned it, in case this was the Panasonic NR equivalent.
Of course the 'smart-arse' answer woould be to read the manual but by my amazing powers of dudection (deliberate miss-spelling) I guess you do not have one. And a google revealed all sorts of scams in an attempt to locate an online edition.
Sure someone will have the 'correct' answer but that soft/sharp slider is intriguing. Given that a result of noise reduction is to soften the image, try placing it at full 'sharp' and then at full 'soft'. Methinks you will notice the difference. I would guess that it is effectively 'off' at full 'sharp'
PS I would edit that topic title to make your question stand out.
Your Super Powers are wrong
... I have the manual (sad I Know, I have original box, plastic bags & even box for the remote) ... and it does not mention NR anywhere.
This is why I thought I'd put up this post as multiple times I'm being told to 'turn NR off'
Gee, that is sad
Try what I suggested.
The sharpening is in the menu.
Now. Has our friend seen the light ?
Unfortunately not on my HS800 model ... only buttons to L or R of tape slot are 'Power on' and 'Eject'
My ADVC110 arrived today ... will try out some tests over next few days.
I think that generation of Panasonic VCRs just has the sharpness slider, and (if you're lucky) a three position hardware (i.e. real, not in a menu) switch labelled something like edit/norm/denoise. The edit position supposedly took something out of circuit for when dubbing VHS>VHS (the results are quite noisy). The norm position gives you the result of the slider, and the denoise position always looked exactly the same as putting the slider to the "soft" setting (to me, in the early/mid 1990s, on a CRT).
> I think that generation of Panasonic VCRs just has the sharpness slider,
yes it has that ..
> a three position hardware switch labelled something like edit/norm/denoise.
Nope ... it has Edit 'off / On'
Manual says this is set to 'On' when using external Edit controller.
I have carried out test as you suggest 3 files uploaded of 'off air' BBC recording - SP VHS PAL same 15 sec clip each time.
Edit is set to OFF
VCR <svideo> ADVC <firewire> PC
Capture with WINDV set to AVI type 2
With slider set at Mid point, at Soft & at Sharp .... each captured as DV and then compressed in VD using Lagarith with no filters or adjustments.
Be interested in your view .... (pun intended)
(BTW - surprising the significant difference in captured file size, between soft & sharp settings - 30%)
Well I will now do my best impression of Kevin Peterson facing Mitch Johnson and fail to duck
Just looked at the two extremes. My impression is that the 'soft' is full noise reduction whereas the 'sharp' has visible noise artifacts.
So my 'capture' with it set to mid 'detent' position is probably the best to use ?
Ultimately it's Tafflad's decision and he should use the one that looks best to him. It's an interesting comparison of what the three Sharpness settings do and thanks, Tafflad, for making them available.
If you look at the scene changes, there are temporal artifacts from both the previous frame(s) and the next frame(s) -- but they exist on all three captures.
Even the "mid" setting is full of halos. Maybe try halfway between soft and mid?
Where's the comparison with "EDIT" on? Does that option disable the sharpness slider?
Last edited by vaporeon800; 29th Dec 2013 at 19:42.
The manual states that edit 'on' is only used when Panasonic external h/w edit controller is used.
No mention of any impact on NR (but who knows)
However happy to try ...Here is same clip - slider to 'mid point' and edit to 'ON'
Last edited by Tafflad; 30th Dec 2013 at 07:44.
Any comments on the 'Clip with Edit On' ??
As a further variable .... as I no longer have TBC .... one suggestion was to use 'Pass Through' on a DVDR
I have captured same clip, with slider set to 'Mid point' Edit off capture path is:
VCR <svideo> DVD E9HH <svideo>ADVC110 <Firewire> PC (WinDV) then cropped and saved as compressed Lagarith
Be interested in your views on comparison with Sample2
Just trying to find out what are best settings.
Panazonic only mention that edit should be 'on' when using external edit controller, but it appears that it changes analogue signal.
I don't know why the EDIT position made the levels better, but if it does that consistently, I'd use it. If it's a freak, I'd be worried about why the levels from your captures aren't consistent.
I would set someone the challenge of taking the soft capture, and making it as sharp as the "middle" capture in AVIsynth. I reckon the middle capture does include some sharpening, but it's approximately the amount you'd want, and so if you can't do better in SW you might as well take advantage of it in the VCR. Except your wedding tape, with its aliasing, might be a different matter.
I would absolutely not use the sharp setting. It's destroying the picture and adding lots of artificial junk that isn't on the tape.
The DVD-R is adding a beneficial TBC to this capture chain, even though (as in the other thread) it's also taming levels (useful again in this case) and softening the picture slightly (not desirable, but barely noticable). It's clipping the left of the picture off this time! Still, I'd use it. Others may disagree.