I've finally gotten ahold of a Hi8 camcorder that I can use to playback (eg. transfer) my hold Hi8 / 8mm tapes onto a DVD or VHS tape.
However, I have a few questions...
1) Should I transfer these tapes to DVD or VHS? VHS has really lousy quality so I'm thinking I should go for DVD.
2) If I transfer to DVD, how should I go about transferring it to my PC? I have an older Happaugae Win-TV GO card (Bt878 chipset I think) that I can use or I can use my Canon MiniDV camcorder (through Firewire) to transfer it to my PC.
3) Which way is FASTER to transfer the video? (MiniDV or capture card) Are they both the same speed? (eg. 1x playback? UGH!)
Try StreamFab Downloader and download from Netflix, Amazon, Youtube! Or Try DVDFab and copy Blu-rays! or rip iTunes movies!
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 12 of 12
Thread
-
-
Every intermidiate transfer will induce quality loose, so direct is the best answer.
Ideally, you want to get a hi-8/8mm player ( maybe thru a video enhancer )and transfer straight to a DVD recorder. -
Yeah, you don't want to go to VHS tape; tape degrades over time.
As far as speed is concerned, SingSing is right - get a DVD stand alone recorder. You just play your tapes while it records in real time, and you have your DVD.
If you use the firewire transfer, you'll still have to convert the resulting AVI file (13 GB per hour) into MPG2 format before you can author a DVD with it. -
3) Which way is FASTER to transfer the video? (MiniDV or capture card) Are they both the same speed? (eg. 1x playback? UGH!)
-
Unfortunately I don't have a standalone DVD recorder and can't justify the purchase for transferring these 8mm tapes...
With that said, can't I use my capture card to capture directly to MPEG-2? Wouldn't that be the best way? (the easiest I'd think would be using MiniDV --> MPEG-2 but then I know there would be AVI --> MPEG-2 conversion) -
Sound like your existing capture card can't capture in DVD mpeg-2, and no budget for a $99 DVD recorder.
In your situation, transfer to miniDV is better. The PC can control a miniDV cam directly, and it won't have the audio/video sync issue often associated with video only capture card. -
You're talking about MiniDV pass-through right? (and not recording to the MiniDV and THEN transferring it to the PC)
Is that going to be the best quality? (using MiniDV over capturing it straight to the PC in RAW AVI or whatever) -
Originally Posted by sofakng
Originally Posted by sofakng
Second, does the Canon MiniDV support "analog pass-thru"?
If so use that.
If not capture to DV tape and then transfer to the computer over IEEE-1394.
Originally Posted by sofakng -
Actually a friend of mine has a Panasonic GS-250 that he just bought. I think it supports analog pass-through so I can use that as look as I can find a way to connect it to my old 8mm camcorder.
Just to make sure though, I should NOT use my PC capture card? I'm just wondering why... -
Originally Posted by sofakng
*But the "garbage in...garbage out" rule still applies. -
Is quality an issue?
What are your computer specs and what software do you plan to use?
A Bt878 has no hardware assist. Realtime encoding using just software requires an extremely powerful computer or a huge quality tradeoff..
The other approach to uncompressed capture requies a fast, tuned hard disk subsystem and quite a bit of learning curve and trial and error. Fully uncompressed video requires ~70 GB/hr. Lossless compression techniques (e.g. huffyuv + CPU) can reduce disk storage about 3x but you still need to expand it back out to filter.
Pass through to DV is more likely to succede with a normal computer but will still require 13.5 GB/hr disk space.
Figure one 2hr. Hi8 tape. You will need 27 GB for capture and ~ 16-18GB to process the DVD. The intermediate DV format will be good for editing and creativity.
If all you want is a direct copy, it starts to make a DVD recorder or a hardware encoding capture card look like a good investment doesn't it.
Similar Threads
-
MiniDV video capture - on screen time/date stamp transfer
By Logan69 in forum Camcorders (DV/HDV/AVCHD/HD)Replies: 24Last Post: 29th Feb 2012, 15:02 -
8mm camcorder capture/transfer
By ViewCam88 in forum CapturingReplies: 0Last Post: 9th Jan 2011, 23:19 -
Unable to transfer some VHS to DVD using AverDVD EzMaker PCI Card
By fromvn in forum Newbie / General discussionsReplies: 4Last Post: 26th Oct 2008, 12:38 -
Top quality professional transfer of 8mm and Super 8mm film
By cosmichippo in forum Video ConversionReplies: 75Last Post: 25th Jul 2007, 22:28 -
Using Capture/Recoding PCI card - GV-650 Video Capture Card
By Confused Chimp in forum CapturingReplies: 1Last Post: 6th May 2007, 18:15