+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 2 of 2
Thread
  1. THE question is right at the bottom (for those who don't want to read all my story)

    I'm using ffmpegX for VCD/SVCD encoding.
    When it comes to VCD, I normally used the appropriate preset (VCD PAL) and the result depends very much on the source (I have the best like the worse).

    However, in the past, there was an option which used ffmpeg engine instead of mpeg2enc. It still exists, as far as I know, it's called fast mpeg1.

    Advantages :
    -It works fast (much faster) than mpeg2enc and the normal VCD preset
    -It has better results (image looks much nicer)

    Disadvantages :
    -It cannot letterbox the movies, so it works correctly (I mean for playback on DVD standalone players) only for 4/3 sources
    -It is not fully VCD compliant : depending on the player, you get randomly not in-sync sound, which re-syncs if you press "pause" and "play" again

    As I really like this encoding (faster and better), I was wondering :

    (HERE'S tHE QUESTION)

    - with the fast mpeg1 option chosen, what makes the mpeg1 output file so different from a standard mpeg1 compliant VCD file ?
    - I saw the sound is 48000 hz instead of 44100 which is in the standard : by demuxing and remuxing with a 44100 hz mp2, does it make it VCD compliant ?
    - is there something different IN the video output ? (GOP etc..) ?

    Thx for any hint.
    Quote Quote  

  2. Originally Posted by Pix
    - with the fast mpeg1 option chosen, what makes the mpeg1 output file so different from a standard mpeg1 compliant VCD file ?
    It is VBR instead of CBR (Toast wil refuse that), and timestamps seem not always correct.

    Originally Posted by Pix
    - I saw the sound is 48000 hz instead of 44100 which is in
    the standard : by demuxing and remuxing with a 44100 hz mp2, does it make it VCD compliant ?
    If source is a DVD then 48Khz leads to better sync with the ffmpeg resampler, though not standard, many players accept it.

    Originally Posted by Pix
    - is there something different IN the video output ? (GOP etc..) ?
    Not really, apart from what said above.
    Quote Quote  




Similar Threads

  1. Only crop mpeg1 file with ffmpegx
    By Paedar in forum ffmpegX general discussion
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 23rd Sep 2007, 16:48
  2. Eye TV: Author DVD with MPEG1 Video Using ffmpegx??
    By midwinter in forum ffmpegX general discussion
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 20th Jul 2003, 02:30
  3. fast mpeg1 conversion.
    By killfire in forum Mac
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 30th Apr 2003, 22:09
  4. ffmpegX : fast mpeg1 encoding and letterboxing ?
    By Pix in forum ffmpegX general discussion
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 30th Jan 2003, 18:31
  5. Fast way to convert avi to mpeg1
    By Asama in forum Video Conversion
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 18th Aug 2001, 10:22
DVDFab DVD to DVD lets you backup DVDs to DVDr, AVI or MP4 for portable devices. More info or download trial!
About   Advertise   Forum   Forum Archive   RSS Feeds   Statistics   Tools